On Mon, Jun 7, 2021 at 11:45 AM Aurélien Aptel <aaptel@xxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Alexander Ahring Oder Aring <aahringo@xxxxxxxxxx> writes: > > as I notice there exists several quic user space implementations, is > > there any interest or process of doing an in-kernel implementation? I > > am asking because I would like to try out quic with an in-kernel > > application protocol like DLM. Besides DLM I've heard that the SMB > > community is also interested into such implementation. > > Yes SMB can work over QUIC. It would be nice if there was an in-kernel > implementation that cifs.ko could use. Many firewall block port 445 > (SMB) despite the newer version of the protocol now having encryption, > signing, etc. Using QUIC (UDP port 443) would allow for more reliable > connectivity to cloud storage like azure. > > There are already multiple well-tested C QUIC implementation out there > (Microsoft one for example, has a lot of extra code annotation to allow > for deep static analysis) but I'm not sure how we would go about porting > it to linux. > > https://github.com/microsoft/msquic Since the Windows implementation of SMB3.1.1 over QUIC appears stable (for quite a while now) and well tested, and even wireshark can now decode it, a possible sequence of steps has been discussed similar to the below: 1) using a userspace port of QUIC (e.g. msquic since is one of the more tested ports, and apparently similar to what already works well for QUIC on Windows with SMB3.1.1) finish up the SMB3.1.1 kernel pieces needed for running over QUIC 2) then switch focus to porting a smaller C userspace implementation of QUIC to Linux (probably not msquic since it is larger and doesn't follow kernel style) to kernel in fs/cifs (since currently SMB3.1.1 is the only protocol that uses QUIC, and the Windows server target is quite stable and can be used to test against) 3) use the userspace upcall example from step 1 for comparison/testing/debugging etc. since we know the userspace version is stable 4) Once SMB3.1.1 over QUIC is no longer experimental, remove, and we are convinced it (kernel QUIC port) works well with SMB3.1.1 to servers which support QUIC, then move the quic code from fs/cifs to the /net tree -- Thanks, Steve
