On Sat, Jun 22, 2024 at 12:12 AM Barry Song <21cnbao@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > From: Barry Song <v-songbaohua@xxxxxxxx> > > -v2: > * add swap-in which can either be aligned or not aligned, by "-a"; > Ying; > * move the program to tools/mm; Ryan; > * try to simulate the scenarios swap is full. Chris; > > -v1: > https://lore.kernel.org/linux-mm/20240620002648.75204-1-21cnbao@xxxxxxxxx/ > > I tested Ryan's RFC patchset[1] and Chris's v3[2] using this v2 tool: > [1] https://lore.kernel.org/linux-mm/20240618232648.4090299-1-ryan.roberts@xxxxxxx/ > [2] https://lore.kernel.org/linux-mm/20240614-swap-allocator-v2-0-2a513b4a7f2f@xxxxxxxxxx/ > > Obviously, we're rarely hitting 100% even in the worst case without "-a" and with > "-s," which is good news! > If swapin is aligned w/ "-a" and w/o "-s", both Chris's and Ryan's patches show > a low fallback ratio though Chris's has the numbers above 0% but Ryan's are 0% > (value A). > > The bad news is that unaligned swapin can significantly increase the fallback ratio, > reaching up to 85% for Ryan's patch and 95% for Chris's patchset without "-s." Both > approaches approach 100% without "-a" and with "-s" (value B). > > I believe real workloads should yield a value between A and B. Without "-a," and > lacking large folios swap-in, this tool randomly swaps in small folios without > considering spatial locality, which is a factor present in real workloads. This > typically results in values higher than A and lower than B. > > Based on the below results, I believe that: > 1. We truly require large folio swap-in to achieve comparable results with > aligned swap-in(based on the result w/o and w/ "-a") > 2. We need a method to prevent small folios from scattering indiscriminately > (based on the result "-a -s") > > * > * Test results on Ryan's patchset: > * > > 1. w/ -a > ./thp_swap_allocator_test -a > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 231, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > ... > Iteration 100: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > > 2. w/o -a > ./thp_swap_allocator_test > > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 208, swpout fallback inc: 25, Fallback percentage: 10.73% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 118, swpout fallback inc: 114, Fallback percentage: 49.14% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 63, swpout fallback inc: 163, Fallback percentage: 72.12% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 45, swpout fallback inc: 178, Fallback percentage: 79.82% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 42, swpout fallback inc: 184, Fallback percentage: 81.42% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 31, swpout fallback inc: 193, Fallback percentage: 86.16% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 27, swpout fallback inc: 201, Fallback percentage: 88.16% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 30, swpout fallback inc: 198, Fallback percentage: 86.84% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 32, swpout fallback inc: 194, Fallback percentage: 85.84% > ... > Iteration 91: swpout inc: 26, swpout fallback inc: 194, Fallback percentage: 88.18% > Iteration 92: swpout inc: 35, swpout fallback inc: 196, Fallback percentage: 84.85% > Iteration 93: swpout inc: 33, swpout fallback inc: 191, Fallback percentage: 85.27% > Iteration 94: swpout inc: 26, swpout fallback inc: 193, Fallback percentage: 88.13% > Iteration 95: swpout inc: 39, swpout fallback inc: 189, Fallback percentage: 82.89% > Iteration 96: swpout inc: 28, swpout fallback inc: 196, Fallback percentage: 87.50% > Iteration 97: swpout inc: 25, swpout fallback inc: 194, Fallback percentage: 88.58% > Iteration 98: swpout inc: 31, swpout fallback inc: 196, Fallback percentage: 86.34% > Iteration 99: swpout inc: 32, swpout fallback inc: 202, Fallback percentage: 86.32% > Iteration 100: swpout inc: 33, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 85.53% > > 3. w/ -a and -s > ./thp_swap_allocator_test -a -s > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.65% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 206, swpout fallback inc: 16, Fallback percentage: 7.21% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 233, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 10: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.32% > Iteration 11: swpout inc: 211, swpout fallback inc: 12, Fallback percentage: 5.38% > Iteration 12: swpout inc: 200, swpout fallback inc: 32, Fallback percentage: 13.79% > Iteration 13: swpout inc: 189, swpout fallback inc: 29, Fallback percentage: 13.30% > Iteration 14: swpout inc: 195, swpout fallback inc: 31, Fallback percentage: 13.72% > Iteration 15: swpout inc: 198, swpout fallback inc: 27, Fallback percentage: 12.00% > Iteration 16: swpout inc: 201, swpout fallback inc: 17, Fallback percentage: 7.80% > Iteration 17: swpout inc: 206, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.83% > Iteration 18: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 5.98% > Iteration 19: swpout inc: 181, swpout fallback inc: 45, Fallback percentage: 19.91% > Iteration 20: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.46% > Iteration 21: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.14% > Iteration 22: swpout inc: 195, swpout fallback inc: 31, Fallback percentage: 13.72% > Iteration 23: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 24: swpout inc: 233, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 25: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.47% > Iteration 26: swpout inc: 229, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.43% > Iteration 27: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.28% > Iteration 28: swpout inc: 211, swpout fallback inc: 15, Fallback percentage: 6.64% > Iteration 29: swpout inc: 188, swpout fallback inc: 40, Fallback percentage: 17.54% > Iteration 30: swpout inc: 207, swpout fallback inc: 18, Fallback percentage: 8.00% > Iteration 31: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 10, Fallback percentage: 4.44% > Iteration 32: swpout inc: 202, swpout fallback inc: 22, Fallback percentage: 9.82% > Iteration 33: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 34: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 10, Fallback percentage: 4.39% > Iteration 35: swpout inc: 203, swpout fallback inc: 30, Fallback percentage: 12.88% > Iteration 36: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.14% > Iteration 37: swpout inc: 211, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.22% > Iteration 38: swpout inc: 193, swpout fallback inc: 28, Fallback percentage: 12.67% > Iteration 39: swpout inc: 210, swpout fallback inc: 20, Fallback percentage: 8.70% > Iteration 40: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.19% > Iteration 41: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.03% > Iteration 42: swpout inc: 200, swpout fallback inc: 23, Fallback percentage: 10.31% > Iteration 43: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.25% > Iteration 44: swpout inc: 206, swpout fallback inc: 18, Fallback percentage: 8.04% > Iteration 45: swpout inc: 210, swpout fallback inc: 11, Fallback percentage: 4.98% > Iteration 46: swpout inc: 204, swpout fallback inc: 19, Fallback percentage: 8.52% > Iteration 47: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 48: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% > Iteration 49: swpout inc: 212, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.75% > Iteration 50: swpout inc: 207, swpout fallback inc: 15, Fallback percentage: 6.76% > Iteration 51: swpout inc: 190, swpout fallback inc: 36, Fallback percentage: 15.93% > Iteration 52: swpout inc: 212, swpout fallback inc: 17, Fallback percentage: 7.42% > Iteration 53: swpout inc: 179, swpout fallback inc: 43, Fallback percentage: 19.37% > Iteration 54: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 55: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.88% > Iteration 56: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.51% > Iteration 57: swpout inc: 203, swpout fallback inc: 25, Fallback percentage: 10.96% > Iteration 58: swpout inc: 213, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.74% > Iteration 59: swpout inc: 207, swpout fallback inc: 18, Fallback percentage: 8.00% > Iteration 60: swpout inc: 216, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.09% > Iteration 61: swpout inc: 183, swpout fallback inc: 34, Fallback percentage: 15.67% > Iteration 62: swpout inc: 184, swpout fallback inc: 39, Fallback percentage: 17.49% > Iteration 63: swpout inc: 184, swpout fallback inc: 39, Fallback percentage: 17.49% > Iteration 64: swpout inc: 210, swpout fallback inc: 15, Fallback percentage: 6.67% > Iteration 65: swpout inc: 178, swpout fallback inc: 48, Fallback percentage: 21.24% > Iteration 66: swpout inc: 188, swpout fallback inc: 30, Fallback percentage: 13.76% > Iteration 67: swpout inc: 193, swpout fallback inc: 29, Fallback percentage: 13.06% > Iteration 68: swpout inc: 202, swpout fallback inc: 22, Fallback percentage: 9.82% > Iteration 69: swpout inc: 213, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.29% > Iteration 70: swpout inc: 204, swpout fallback inc: 15, Fallback percentage: 6.85% > Iteration 71: swpout inc: 180, swpout fallback inc: 45, Fallback percentage: 20.00% > Iteration 72: swpout inc: 210, swpout fallback inc: 21, Fallback percentage: 9.09% > Iteration 73: swpout inc: 216, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.14% > Iteration 74: swpout inc: 209, swpout fallback inc: 19, Fallback percentage: 8.33% > Iteration 75: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.06% > Iteration 76: swpout inc: 212, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.19% > Iteration 77: swpout inc: 188, swpout fallback inc: 41, Fallback percentage: 17.90% > Iteration 78: swpout inc: 198, swpout fallback inc: 17, Fallback percentage: 7.91% > Iteration 79: swpout inc: 209, swpout fallback inc: 16, Fallback percentage: 7.11% > Iteration 80: swpout inc: 182, swpout fallback inc: 41, Fallback percentage: 18.39% > Iteration 81: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.46% > Iteration 82: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.32% > Iteration 83: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.48% > Iteration 84: swpout inc: 201, swpout fallback inc: 21, Fallback percentage: 9.46% > Iteration 85: swpout inc: 211, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.40% > Iteration 86: swpout inc: 209, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.28% > Iteration 87: swpout inc: 181, swpout fallback inc: 42, Fallback percentage: 18.83% > Iteration 88: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.76% > Iteration 89: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.14% > Iteration 90: swpout inc: 192, swpout fallback inc: 33, Fallback percentage: 14.67% > Iteration 91: swpout inc: 184, swpout fallback inc: 31, Fallback percentage: 14.42% > Iteration 92: swpout inc: 201, swpout fallback inc: 32, Fallback percentage: 13.73% > Iteration 93: swpout inc: 181, swpout fallback inc: 40, Fallback percentage: 18.10% > Iteration 94: swpout inc: 211, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.22% > Iteration 95: swpout inc: 198, swpout fallback inc: 25, Fallback percentage: 11.21% > Iteration 96: swpout inc: 205, swpout fallback inc: 22, Fallback percentage: 9.69% > Iteration 97: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 12, Fallback percentage: 5.22% > Iteration 98: swpout inc: 203, swpout fallback inc: 25, Fallback percentage: 10.96% > Iteration 99: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 12, Fallback percentage: 5.22% > Iteration 100: swpout inc: 195, swpout fallback inc: 34, Fallback percentage: 14.85% > > 4. w/o -a and w/ -s > thp_swap_allocator_test -s > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 173, swpout fallback inc: 60, Fallback percentage: 25.75% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 85, swpout fallback inc: 147, Fallback percentage: 63.36% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 39, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 83.33% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 13, swpout fallback inc: 220, Fallback percentage: 94.42% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 10, swpout fallback inc: 215, Fallback percentage: 95.56% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 9, swpout fallback inc: 219, Fallback percentage: 96.05% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 217, Fallback percentage: 97.31% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 215, Fallback percentage: 97.29% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 0, swpout fallback inc: 225, Fallback percentage: 100.00% > Iteration 10: swpout inc: 1, swpout fallback inc: 229, Fallback percentage: 99.57% > Iteration 11: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 216, Fallback percentage: 99.08% > Iteration 12: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 229, Fallback percentage: 99.13% > Iteration 13: swpout inc: 4, swpout fallback inc: 211, Fallback percentage: 98.14% > Iteration 14: swpout inc: 1, swpout fallback inc: 221, Fallback percentage: 99.55% > Iteration 15: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 223, Fallback percentage: 99.11% > Iteration 16: swpout inc: 3, swpout fallback inc: 224, Fallback percentage: 98.68% > Iteration 17: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 231, Fallback percentage: 99.14% > ... > > * > * Test results on Chris's v3 patchset: > * > 1. w/ -a > ./thp_swap_allocator_test -a > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 231, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.25% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 12, Fallback percentage: 5.29% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 213, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.17% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 207, swpout fallback inc: 15, Fallback percentage: 6.76% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 193, swpout fallback inc: 33, Fallback percentage: 14.60% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 13, Fallback percentage: 5.73% > Iteration 10: swpout inc: 199, swpout fallback inc: 25, Fallback percentage: 11.16% > Iteration 11: swpout inc: 208, swpout fallback inc: 14, Fallback percentage: 6.31% > Iteration 12: swpout inc: 203, swpout fallback inc: 31, Fallback percentage: 13.25% > Iteration 13: swpout inc: 192, swpout fallback inc: 25, Fallback percentage: 11.52% > Iteration 14: swpout inc: 193, swpout fallback inc: 36, Fallback percentage: 15.72% > Iteration 15: swpout inc: 188, swpout fallback inc: 33, Fallback percentage: 14.93% My working in progress allocator patch: linux# ../thp_swap_allocator_test -a Iteration 1: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 2: swpout inc: 231, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 3: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 4: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 5: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 6: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 7: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 8: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 9: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 10: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 11: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 12: swpout inc: 234, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 13: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 14: swpout inc: 229, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 15: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 16: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 17: swpout inc: 232, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 18: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 19: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 20: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 21: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 22: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 23: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 24: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 25: swpout inc: 212, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 26: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 27: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 28: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 29: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% ... Fall back zero between. ... Iteration 78: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 79: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 80: swpout inc: 230, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 81: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 82: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.21% Iteration 83: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% Iteration 84: swpout inc: 230, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 85: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 86: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 87: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 88: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 89: swpout inc: 232, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.43% Iteration 90: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.20% Iteration 91: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 92: swpout inc: 229, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 93: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 94: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 95: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 96: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 97: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 98: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 99: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 100: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Occasionally I can get a full 0.00% run, the above is more typical. > ... > > It seems Chris's approach can be negatively affected even by aligned swapin, > having a low fallback ratio but not 0% while Ryan's patchset hasn't this > issue. > > 2. w/o -a > ./thp_swap_allocator_test My WIP patch: linux# ../thp_swap_allocator_test Iteration 1: swpout inc: 233, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 2: swpout inc: 146, swpout fallback inc: 86, Fallback percentage: 37.07% Iteration 3: swpout inc: 75, swpout fallback inc: 151, Fallback percentage: 66.81% Iteration 4: swpout inc: 52, swpout fallback inc: 171, Fallback percentage: 76.68% Iteration 5: swpout inc: 47, swpout fallback inc: 179, Fallback percentage: 79.20% Iteration 6: swpout inc: 40, swpout fallback inc: 184, Fallback percentage: 82.14% Iteration 7: swpout inc: 40, swpout fallback inc: 188, Fallback percentage: 82.46% Iteration 8: swpout inc: 39, swpout fallback inc: 189, Fallback percentage: 82.89% Iteration 9: swpout inc: 38, swpout fallback inc: 188, Fallback percentage: 83.19% Iteration 10: swpout inc: 41, swpout fallback inc: 187, Fallback percentage: 82.02% Iteration 11: swpout inc: 32, swpout fallback inc: 197, Fallback percentage: 86.03% Iteration 12: swpout inc: 31, swpout fallback inc: 189, Fallback percentage: 85.91% Iteration 13: swpout inc: 31, swpout fallback inc: 197, Fallback percentage: 86.40% Iteration 14: swpout inc: 29, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 87.05% Iteration 15: swpout inc: 32, swpout fallback inc: 194, Fallback percentage: 85.84% Iteration 16: swpout inc: 25, swpout fallback inc: 190, Fallback percentage: 88.37% Iteration 17: swpout inc: 31, swpout fallback inc: 198, Fallback percentage: 86.46% Iteration 18: swpout inc: 27, swpout fallback inc: 200, Fallback percentage: 88.11% Iteration 19: swpout inc: 29, swpout fallback inc: 189, Fallback percentage: 86.70% Iteration 20: swpout inc: 26, swpout fallback inc: 194, Fallback percentage: 88.18% Iteration 21: swpout inc: 24, swpout fallback inc: 201, Fallback percentage: 89.33% Iteration 22: swpout inc: 28, swpout fallback inc: 202, Fallback percentage: 87.83% Iteration 23: swpout inc: 31, swpout fallback inc: 198, Fallback percentage: 86.46% Iteration 24: swpout inc: 32, swpout fallback inc: 194, Fallback percentage: 85.84% Iteration 25: swpout inc: 30, swpout fallback inc: 199, Fallback percentage: 86.90% Iteration 26: swpout inc: 38, swpout fallback inc: 193, Fallback percentage: 83.55% Iteration 27: swpout inc: 28, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 87.44% Iteration 28: swpout inc: 29, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 87.05% Iteration 29: swpout inc: 34, swpout fallback inc: 191, Fallback percentage: 84.89% Iteration 30: swpout inc: 28, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 87.44% Iteration 31: swpout inc: 36, swpout fallback inc: 184, Fallback percentage: 83.64% Iteration 32: swpout inc: 38, swpout fallback inc: 187, Fallback percentage: 83.11% Iteration 33: swpout inc: 37, swpout fallback inc: 192, Fallback percentage: 83.84% Iteration 34: swpout inc: 39, swpout fallback inc: 191, Fallback percentage: 83.04% Iteration 35: swpout inc: 30, swpout fallback inc: 197, Fallback percentage: 86.78% Iteration 36: swpout inc: 34, swpout fallback inc: 195, Fallback percentage: 85.15% Iteration 37: swpout inc: 35, swpout fallback inc: 182, Fallback percentage: 83.87% Iteration 38: swpout inc: 29, swpout fallback inc: 196, Fallback percentage: 87.11% Iteration 39: swpout inc: 33, swpout fallback inc: 190, Fallback percentage: 85.20% Iteration 40: swpout inc: 33, swpout fallback inc: 184, Fallback percentage: 84.79% Iteration 41: swpout inc: 30, swpout fallback inc: 188, Fallback percentage: 86.24% Iteration 42: swpout inc: 35, swpout fallback inc: 190, Fallback percentage: 84.44% Iteration 43: swpout inc: 30, swpout fallback inc: 193, Fallback percentage: 86.55% > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 209, swpout fallback inc: 24, Fallback percentage: 10.30% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 100, swpout fallback inc: 132, Fallback percentage: 56.90% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 43, swpout fallback inc: 183, Fallback percentage: 80.97% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 30, swpout fallback inc: 193, Fallback percentage: 86.55% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 21, swpout fallback inc: 205, Fallback percentage: 90.71% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 10, swpout fallback inc: 214, Fallback percentage: 95.54% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 16, swpout fallback inc: 212, Fallback percentage: 92.98% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 9, swpout fallback inc: 219, Fallback percentage: 96.05% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 220, Fallback percentage: 97.35% > Iteration 10: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 221, Fallback percentage: 96.93% > Iteration 11: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 222, Fallback percentage: 96.94% > Iteration 12: swpout inc: 8, swpout fallback inc: 212, Fallback percentage: 96.36% > .. > > Ryan's fallback ratio(around 85%) seems to be a little better while both are much > worse than "-a". > > 3. w/ -a and -s > ./thp_swap_allocator_test -a -s My WIP patch: linux# ../thp_swap_allocator_test -a -s Iteration 1: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 2: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 3: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 4: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 5: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 6: swpout inc: 233, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 7: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.79% Iteration 8: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 9: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 10: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.44% Iteration 11: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 12: swpout inc: 232, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 13: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 14: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.21% Iteration 15: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 16: swpout inc: 218, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 17: swpout inc: 209, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.42% Iteration 18: swpout inc: 233, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.43% Iteration 19: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.10% Iteration 20: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.60% Iteration 21: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 22: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 23: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 24: swpout inc: 233, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 25: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 26: swpout inc: 230, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 27: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 28: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.88% Iteration 29: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.32% Iteration 30: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 31: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.44% Iteration 32: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 33: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% Iteration 34: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 35: swpout inc: 229, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.72% Iteration 36: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 37: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 38: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.45% Iteration 39: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.30% Iteration 40: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.19% Iteration 41: swpout inc: 231, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 42: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% Iteration 43: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 44: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 45: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% Iteration 46: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 47: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 48: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.45% Iteration 49: swpout inc: 216, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.92% Iteration 50: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 51: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 52: swpout inc: 229, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 53: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% Iteration 54: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 55: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 56: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.19% Iteration 57: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.88% Iteration 58: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.83% Iteration 59: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.33% Iteration 60: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.30% Iteration 61: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.92% Iteration 62: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 9, Fallback percentage: 4.04% Iteration 63: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.35% Iteration 64: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.22% Iteration 65: swpout inc: 216, swpout fallback inc: 10, Fallback percentage: 4.42% Iteration 66: swpout inc: 213, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.29% Iteration 67: swpout inc: 212, swpout fallback inc: 10, Fallback percentage: 4.50% Iteration 68: swpout inc: 216, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.57% Iteration 69: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.83% Iteration 70: swpout inc: 209, swpout fallback inc: 10, Fallback percentage: 4.57% Iteration 71: swpout inc: 217, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.56% Iteration 72: swpout inc: 231, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 73: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.59% Iteration 74: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.07% Iteration 75: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.49% Iteration 76: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.10% Iteration 76: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.10% Iteration 77: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 8, Fallback percentage: 3.49% Iteration 78: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.47% Iteration 79: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.89% Iteration 80: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.35% Iteration 81: swpout inc: 216, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.92% Iteration 82: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.32% Iteration 83: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.87% Iteration 84: swpout inc: 222, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 85: swpout inc: 214, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 86: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 87: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 88: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 89: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.19% Iteration 90: swpout inc: 225, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 91: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% Iteration 92: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.15% Iteration 93: swpout inc: 219, swpout fallback inc: 2, Fallback percentage: 0.90% Iteration 94: swpout inc: 221, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.78% Iteration 95: swpout inc: 220, swpout fallback inc: 3, Fallback percentage: 1.35% Iteration 96: swpout inc: 211, swpout fallback inc: 16, Fallback percentage: 7.05% Iteration 97: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.61% Iteration 98: swpout inc: 223, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.19% Iteration 99: swpout inc: 226, swpout fallback inc: 4, Fallback percentage: 1.74% Iteration 100: swpout inc: 228, swpout fallback inc: 1, Fallback percentage: 0.44% > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 224, swpout fallback inc: 0, Fallback percentage: 0.00% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 213, swpout fallback inc: 5, Fallback percentage: 2.29% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 7, Fallback percentage: 3.15% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 210, swpout fallback inc: 16, Fallback percentage: 7.08% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 212, swpout fallback inc: 10, Fallback percentage: 4.50% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 215, swpout fallback inc: 18, Fallback percentage: 7.73% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 181, swpout fallback inc: 43, Fallback percentage: 19.20% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 173, swpout fallback inc: 55, Fallback percentage: 24.12% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 163, swpout fallback inc: 54, Fallback percentage: 24.88% > Iteration 10: swpout inc: 168, swpout fallback inc: 59, Fallback percentage: 25.99% > Iteration 11: swpout inc: 154, swpout fallback inc: 69, Fallback percentage: 30.94% > Iteration 12: swpout inc: 166, swpout fallback inc: 66, Fallback percentage: 28.45% > Iteration 13: swpout inc: 165, swpout fallback inc: 53, Fallback percentage: 24.31% > Iteration 14: swpout inc: 158, swpout fallback inc: 68, Fallback percentage: 30.09% > Iteration 15: swpout inc: 168, swpout fallback inc: 57, Fallback percentage: 25.33% > Iteration 16: swpout inc: 165, swpout fallback inc: 53, Fallback percentage: 24.31% > Iteration 17: swpout inc: 163, swpout fallback inc: 49, Fallback percentage: 23.11% > Iteration 18: swpout inc: 172, swpout fallback inc: 62, Fallback percentage: 26.50% > Iteration 19: swpout inc: 183, swpout fallback inc: 43, Fallback percentage: 19.03% > Iteration 20: swpout inc: 158, swpout fallback inc: 73, Fallback percentage: 31.60% > Iteration 21: swpout inc: 147, swpout fallback inc: 81, Fallback percentage: 35.53% > Iteration 22: swpout inc: 140, swpout fallback inc: 86, Fallback percentage: 38.05% > Iteration 23: swpout inc: 144, swpout fallback inc: 79, Fallback percentage: 35.43% > Iteration 24: swpout inc: 132, swpout fallback inc: 101, Fallback percentage: 43.35% > Iteration 25: swpout inc: 133, swpout fallback inc: 82, Fallback percentage: 38.14% > Iteration 26: swpout inc: 152, swpout fallback inc: 78, Fallback percentage: 33.91% > Iteration 27: swpout inc: 138, swpout fallback inc: 81, Fallback percentage: 36.99% > Iteration 28: swpout inc: 152, swpout fallback inc: 74, Fallback percentage: 32.74% > Iteration 29: swpout inc: 153, swpout fallback inc: 75, Fallback percentage: 32.89% > Iteration 30: swpout inc: 151, swpout fallback inc: 74, Fallback percentage: 32.89% > ... > > Chris's approach appears to be more susceptible to negative effects from > small folios. > > 4. w/o -a and w/ -s My current WIP patch: linux# ../thp_swap_allocator_test -s Iteration 1: swpout inc: 227, swpout fallback inc: 6, Fallback percentage: 2.58% Iteration 2: swpout inc: 91, swpout fallback inc: 141, Fallback percentage: 60.78% Iteration 3: swpout inc: 36, swpout fallback inc: 198, Fallback percentage: 84.62% Iteration 4: swpout inc: 19, swpout fallback inc: 214, Fallback percentage: 91.85% Iteration 5: swpout inc: 12, swpout fallback inc: 213, Fallback percentage: 94.67% Iteration 6: swpout inc: 11, swpout fallback inc: 217, Fallback percentage: 95.18% Iteration 7: swpout inc: 8, swpout fallback inc: 215, Fallback percentage: 96.41% Iteration 8: swpout inc: 8, swpout fallback inc: 213, Fallback percentage: 96.38% Iteration 9: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 223, Fallback percentage: 99.11% Iteration 10: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 223, Fallback percentage: 96.96% Iteration 11: swpout inc: 5, swpout fallback inc: 213, Fallback percentage: 97.71% Iteration 12: swpout inc: 8, swpout fallback inc: 223, Fallback percentage: 96.54% Iteration 13: swpout inc: 4, swpout fallback inc: 211, Fallback percentage: 98.14% Iteration 14: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 216, Fallback percentage: 97.30% Iteration 15: swpout inc: 9, swpout fallback inc: 216, Fallback percentage: 96.00% Iteration 16: swpout inc: 9, swpout fallback inc: 218, Fallback percentage: 96.04% Iteration 17: swpout inc: 10, swpout fallback inc: 223, Fallback percentage: 95.71% Iteration 18: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 211, Fallback percentage: 96.79% Iteration 19: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 220, Fallback percentage: 96.92% Iteration 20: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 220, Fallback percentage: 96.92% Iteration 21: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 221, Fallback percentage: 97.36% Iteration 22: swpout inc: 5, swpout fallback inc: 227, Fallback percentage: 97.84% Iteration 23: swpout inc: 4, swpout fallback inc: 213, Fallback percentage: 98.16% Iteration 24: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 218, Fallback percentage: 97.32% Iteration 25: swpout inc: 6, swpout fallback inc: 214, Fallback percentage: 97.27% Iteration 26: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 221, Fallback percentage: 96.93% Iteration 27: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 216, Fallback percentage: 96.86% Iteration 28: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 214, Fallback percentage: 96.83% Chris > ./thp_swap_allocator_test -s > Iteration 1: swpout inc: 183, swpout fallback inc: 50, Fallback percentage: 21.46% > Iteration 2: swpout inc: 75, swpout fallback inc: 157, Fallback percentage: 67.67% > Iteration 3: swpout inc: 33, swpout fallback inc: 201, Fallback percentage: 85.90% > Iteration 4: swpout inc: 11, swpout fallback inc: 222, Fallback percentage: 95.28% > Iteration 5: swpout inc: 10, swpout fallback inc: 215, Fallback percentage: 95.56% > Iteration 6: swpout inc: 7, swpout fallback inc: 221, Fallback percentage: 96.93% > Iteration 7: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 221, Fallback percentage: 99.10% > Iteration 8: swpout inc: 4, swpout fallback inc: 217, Fallback percentage: 98.19% > Iteration 9: swpout inc: 0, swpout fallback inc: 225, Fallback percentage: 100.00% > Iteration 10: swpout inc: 3, swpout fallback inc: 227, Fallback percentage: 98.70% > Iteration 11: swpout inc: 1, swpout fallback inc: 217, Fallback percentage: 99.54% > Iteration 12: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 229, Fallback percentage: 99.13% > Iteration 13: swpout inc: 1, swpout fallback inc: 214, Fallback percentage: 99.53% > Iteration 14: swpout inc: 2, swpout fallback inc: 220, Fallback percentage: 99.10% > Iteration 15: swpout inc: 1, swpout fallback inc: 224, Fallback percentage: 99.56% > Iteration 16: swpout inc: 3, swpout fallback inc: 224, Fallback percentage: 98.68% > ... > > Barry Song (1): > tools/mm: Introduce a tool to assess swap entry allocation for > thp_swapout > > tools/mm/Makefile | 2 +- > tools/mm/thp_swap_allocator_test.c | 233 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ > 2 files changed, 234 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) > create mode 100644 tools/mm/thp_swap_allocator_test.c > > -- > 2.34.1 > >
