On 5/3/22 15:35, Alistair Popple wrote: > Not entirely true. The GPUs on POWER9 have performance counters capable of > collecting this kind of information for memory accessed from the GPU. I will > admit though that sadly most people probably don't have a P9 sitting under their > desk :) Well, x86 CPUs have performance monitoring hardware that can theoretically collect physical access information too. But, this performance monitoring hardware wasn't designed for this specific use case in mind. So, in practice, these events (PEBS) weren't very useful for driving memory tiering. Are you saying that the GPUs on POWER9 have performance counters that can drive memory tiering in practice? I'd be curious if there's working code to show how they get used. Maybe the hardware is better than the x86 PMU or the software consuming it is more clever than what we did. But, I'd love to see it either way.
