[Let's CC i915 people - the email thread started here: http://lkml.kernel.org/r/e994b0a76099437b8edbae925e9ccac8@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Long story short, there is a swap out activity even when there is a clean page cache available that could be reclaimed and there is a suspicion that the i915 shrinker might be involved. Could you guys have a look please?] On Sun 02-02-20 22:56:56, Chris Edwards wrote: > ________________________________________ > From: Johannes Weiner <hannes@xxxxxxxxxxx> > Sent: Thursday, 30 January 2020 05:39 > > > Chris, could you trace the i915 shrinker? > > > > Enable the shrinker trace point: > > > > # echo 1 >/sys/kernel/debug/tracing/events/i915/i915_gem_shrink/enable > > > > Then watch for events while the swapping is occuring: > > > > # cat /sys/kernel/debug/tracing/trace > > ________________________________________ > > Thanks Johannes - that seems to confirm your suspicion: the kernel trace has a lot of contiguous entries relating to kswapd and the i915 shrinker: > > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251812.619380: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=243, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.194977: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=496, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.196205: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=850, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.196207: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=808, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.399428: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=470, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.429971: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=666, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.430039: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=259, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.905045: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=573, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.905085: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=174, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .N.. 251813.945542: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=670, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251813.945569: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=474, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251814.734973: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=611, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251814.735024: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=417, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251814.807983: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=990, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251814.807998: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=962, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251815.146950: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=860, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251815.146970: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=758, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251815.257367: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=924, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251815.257384: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=832, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.036147: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=576, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.036166: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=140, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.123591: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=403, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.124549: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=546, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.125415: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=546, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.126478: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=546, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.127380: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=542, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.128163: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=522, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.128748: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=522, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.129303: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=522, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.131522: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=522, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.133711: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=522, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.134317: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=568, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.134849: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=568, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.135647: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=568, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.233664: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=483, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.234041: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=858, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.234060: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=612, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.818646: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=654, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.818702: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=400, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.865547: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=676, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251816.865570: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=499, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.299401: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=556, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.299435: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=355, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.301099: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=566, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.301112: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=512, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.369283: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=749, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.369385: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=115, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.911052: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=605, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.911080: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=474, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.964954: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=709, flags=3 > kswapd0-90 [000] .... 251817.964973: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=589, flags=17 > kswapd0-90 [001] .... 251819.005872: i915_gem_shrink: dev=0, target=490, flags=3 > > Thanks - and Michal, I hope you had a nice holiday. :) > -- > Chris -- Michal Hocko SUSE Labs
