On 9/16/19 1:16 PM, David Rientjes wrote: > On Fri, 16 Aug 2019, Nitin Gupta wrote: ... > > We've had good success with periodically compacting memory on a regular > cadence on systems with hugepages enabled. The cadence itself is defined > by the admin but it causes khugepaged[*] to periodically wakeup and invoke > compaction in an attempt to keep zones as defragmented as possible That's an important data point, thanks for reporting it. And given that we have at least one data point validating it, I think we should feel fairly comfortable with this approach. Because the sys admin probably knows when are the best times to steal cpu cycles and recover some huge pages. Unlike the kernel, the sys admin can actually see the future sometimes, because he/she may know what is going to be run. It's still sounding like we can expect excellent results from simply defragmenting from user space, via a chron job and/or before running important tests, rather than trying to have the kernel guess whether it's a performance win to defragment at some particular time. Are you using existing interfaces, or did you need to add something? How exactly are you triggering compaction? thanks, -- John Hubbard NVIDIA
