On Wed 08-08-18 21:57:13, Tetsuo Handa wrote: [...] > Also, before the OOM reaper was introduced, we waited until TIF_MEMDIE is > cleared from the OOM victim thread. Compared to pre OOM reaper era, giving up > so early is certainly a regression. We did clear TIF_MEMDIE flag after mmput() in do_exit so this was not a silver bullet either. Any reference on the mm_struct would lead to a similar problem. So could you please stop making strong stamements and start being reasonable? Yeah, this is racy. Nobody is claiming otherwise. All we are trying to say is that this area is full of dragons and before we start making it more complicating by covering weird cornercases we really need to see that those corner cases happen in real workloads. Otherwise we end up with a unmaintainable and fragile mess. And more importantly this is _not_ what this patch is trying to address so please do not go tangent again. I really do not know how to send this simply message to you. I have tried so many times before. -- Michal Hocko SUSE Labs
