On Mon, Jun 06, 2011 at 11:55:44PM +0200, Andreas Steinel wrote: > Hi Jürgen, Hi List, Hi! > > Thank you for your answer. > > On Sat, Jun 4, 2011 at 4:34 PM, Juergen Lock <nox@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Ok let me try... > > > > 1. Your remote is the same as in this (googled) picture? > > > > http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_B0OTxmaxXPU/SfL1yGqvGjI/AAAAAAAAABU/GFOklS4R9GM/s320/tt_s2_3650.jpg > > At first glance yes, but it is not. Very similar, but yet different. > (also discovered in the source, please see above) > Hm, interesting. > > 2. Do you see remote events logged in dmesg when you modprobe the > > pctv452e driver with debug=3 and then test the remote? > > Oh yes, I can see events from the remote: > [ 8108.169526] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x0d sys=0x18 > [ 8108.273332] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x0d sys=0x18 > [ 8108.473326] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x0d sys=0x18 > > > > 3. You can also test for events coming in on /dev/input/event8 using > > evtest, or (if you have up-to-date v4l-utils) using ir-keytable: > > None of them showed any keyinput, but it is recognized (now its on event1): > > Input driver version is 1.0.0 > Input device ID: bus 0x3 vendor 0xb48 product 0x300a version 0x101 > Input device name: "IR-receiver inside an USB DVB receiver" > Supported events: > Event type 0 (Sync) > Event type 1 (Key) > Event code 2 (1) > Event code 3 (2) > Event code 4 (3) > Event code 5 (4) > Event code 6 (5) > Event code 7 (6) > Event code 8 (7) > Event code 9 (8) > Event code 10 (9) > Event code 11 (0) > Event code 103 (Up) > Event code 105 (Left) > Event code 106 (Right) > Event code 108 (Down) > Event code 113 (Mute) > Event code 114 (VolumeDown) > Event code 115 (VolumeUp) > Event code 116 (Power) > Event code 119 (Pause) > Event code 128 (Stop) > Event code 141 (Setup) > Event code 159 (Forward) > Event code 167 (Record) > Event code 168 (Rewind) > Event code 174 (Exit) > Event code 207 (Play) > Event code 352 (Ok) > Event code 357 (Option) > Event code 358 (Info) > Event code 365 (EPG) > Event code 373 (Mode) > Event code 388 (Text) > Event code 398 (Red) > Event code 399 (Green) > Event code 400 (Yellow) > Event code 401 (Blue) > Event code 402 (ChannelUp) > Event code 403 (ChannelDown) > Event code 410 (Shuffle) > > But no event is registered there :-/ > > ir-keytable doesn't found any rc even after triggering the udev rules > (v4l ir-keytable from git and from debian unstable package). > > > 4. Do you use the lirc devinput driver and the lircd.conf.devinput > > config? Maybe this post helps: > > > > http://forum.xbmc.org/showthread.php?t=101151 > > This link is - according to the headline - only for 2.6.35+ and I' > running 2.6.32 (Squeeze default kernel) Ah I missed that, sorry. > and the post also builds on > ir-keytable, which is not working properly. > *nod* > Yet, i further investigated the errors and the source code and turned > on dvb-usb-debugging which yields: > > [11423.302006] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > [11423.501806] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [11423.501815] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > [11423.701615] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [11423.701628] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > [11424.001763] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [11424.001775] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > [11424.102026] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [11424.102034] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > [11424.202030] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [11424.202038] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > > Which explains the error. I further debugged the problem and found this: > > [13242.485965] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > [13242.585948] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [13242.585955] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x01 > [13242.585960] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x02 > [13242.585964] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x03 > [13242.585968] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x04 > [13242.585972] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x05 > [13242.585976] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x06 > [13242.585980] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x07 > [13242.585983] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x08 > [13242.585987] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x09 > [13242.585991] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0a > [13242.585995] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0b > [13242.585999] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0c > [13242.586003] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0d > [13242.586007] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0e > [13242.586010] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0f > [13242.586014] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x10 > [13242.586018] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x11 > [13242.586022] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x12 > [13242.586026] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x13 > [13242.586030] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x14 > [13242.586034] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x15 > [13242.586037] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x16 > [13242.586041] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x17 > [13242.586045] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x18 > [13242.586049] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x19 > [13242.586053] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x1a > [13242.586057] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x21 > [13242.586061] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x22 > [13242.586064] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x23 > [13242.586068] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x24 > [13242.586072] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x25 > [13242.586076] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x26 > [13242.586080] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x27 > [13242.586084] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3a > [13242.586088] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3b > [13242.586092] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3c > [13242.586095] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3d > [13242.586099] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3e > [13242.586103] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3f > [13242.586106] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > > I patched the file to get one key responding, but unfortunately > failed. The problem is not obvious to me: > > diff -r 41388e396e0f linux/drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/dvb-usb-remote.c > --- a/linux/drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/dvb-usb-remote.c Mon May 23 > 00:50:21 2011 +0300 > +++ b/linux/drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/dvb-usb-remote.c Mon Jun 06 > 23:53:27 2011 +0200 > @@ -272,6 +272,8 @@ > } > /* See if we can match the raw key code. */ > for (i = 0; i < d->props.rc_key_map_size; i++) > + printk(" keycode is [1]=0x%02x vs rc5_custom=0x%02x, > [3]=0x%02x vs rc5_custom=0x%02x\n", > + keybuf[1], rc5_custom(&keymap[i]), keybuf[3], > rc5_data(&keymap[i])); > if (rc5_custom(&keymap[i]) == keybuf[1] && > rc5_data(&keymap[i]) == keybuf[3]) { > *event = keymap[i].event; You forgot the curly brackets there, now the for loop only runs the printf... > diff -r 41388e396e0f linux/drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/pctv452e.c > --- a/linux/drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/pctv452e.c Mon May 23 > 00:50:21 2011 +0300 > +++ b/linux/drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/pctv452e.c Mon Jun 06 > 23:53:27 2011 +0200 > @@ -604,7 +604,8 @@ > {0x153c, KEY_STOP}, > {0x153d, KEY_REWIND}, > {0x153e, KEY_PAUSE}, > - {0x153f, KEY_FORWARD} > + {0x153f, KEY_FORWARD}, > + {0x1826, KEY_OK} > }; > > Leads to > > [13902.063002] pctv452e_rc_query: cmd=0x26 sys=0x18 > [13902.063013] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x01 > [13902.063017] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x02 > [13902.063021] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x03 > [13902.063025] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x04 > [13902.063029] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x05 > [13902.063033] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x06 > [13902.063037] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x07 > [13902.063041] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x08 > [13902.063045] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x09 > [13902.063048] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0a > [13902.063052] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0b > [13902.063056] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0c > [13902.063060] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0d > [13902.063063] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0e > [13902.063067] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x0f > [13902.063071] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x10 > [13902.063075] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x11 > [13902.063078] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x12 > [13902.063082] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x13 > [13902.063086] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x14 > [13902.063090] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x15 > [13902.063094] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x16 > [13902.063098] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x17 > [13902.063101] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x18 > [13902.063105] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x19 > [13902.063109] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x1a > [13902.063113] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x21 > [13902.063117] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x22 > [13902.063120] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x23 > [13902.063124] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x24 > [13902.063128] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x25 > [13902.063132] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x26 > [13902.063136] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x27 > [13902.063139] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3a > [13902.063143] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3b > [13902.063147] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3c > [13902.063151] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3d > [13902.063154] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3e > [13902.063158] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x15, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x3f > [13902.063162] keycode is [1]=0x18 vs rc5_custom=0x18, [3]=0x26 vs > rc5_custom=0x26 > [13902.063166] key mapping failed - no appropriate key found in keymapping > > Any further ideas? See above. :) HTH, Juergen -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-media" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
