Re: [PATCH 09/10] edid-decode: DisplayID additions

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



1)
Yes, my displayid_vesa_dmt_timings contains the same info as displayid_vesa_dmt.

displayid_vesa_dmt was added after I had created parse_displayid_timing which uses displayid_vesa_dmt_timings and displayid_cta_timings for " Type 1 VESA DMT Timings Block" and " CTA Timings Block".

Three options:
a) remove displayid_vesa_dmt_timings
b) keep parse_displayid_timing, displayid_vesa_dmt_timings, and displayid_cta_timings; remove displayid_vesa_dmt.
c) replace displayid_cta_timings with a displayid_cta array containing elements of the same type as displayid_vesa_dmt; rewrite parse_displayid_timing to use displayid_vesa_dmt  (like "Type 1 VESA DMT Timings Block" does), and displayid_cta : only problem here is that cta has floats for refresh rate.

1a is probably the best choice as suggested by the answer to your next question:

2)
Yes, displayid_cta_timings is identical to edid_cta_modes1 (only the first 64 VICs are used). I don't think I noticed that before. My displayid_cta_timings contains extra info about refresh rates that are not integer (23.97/24Hz, 59.94/60Hz, 29.97/30Hz, 119.88/120Hz, 239.76/240Hz). It also shows the 1440 wide timings are double clocked from 720. It has the correct interlaced flag for VIC 44 and 45. Perhaps that info could be placed into edid_cta_modes1 and edid_cta_modes2 (we could also add info about the H and V blanking front porch, width, and back porch). Then displayid_cta_timings can be removed. Then we do 1a above and rewrite parse_displayid_timing to use edid_cta_modes1 (with the modifications from displayid_cta_timings)

3)
See #1 above. The "#if 0" is there to show how I used parse_displayid_timing with displayid_vesa_dmt_timings before displayid_vesa_dmt was created. The changes suggested in #2 will remove that.


On 2019-11-24, 2:03 AM, "Hans Verkuil" <hverkuil@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

    Hi Joe,
    
    I have a few comments about this patch. See below:
    
    On 11/23/19 5:46 PM, joevt wrote:
    > - Decode "Display Parameters Block". Example in lg-ultrafine-5k*
    > - Decode "CTA Timings Block". Similar to "Type 1 VESA DMT Timings Block".
    > - Decode "GP ASCII String Block". Example in dell-up2715k-mdp-switchresx
    > 
    > - Added DisplayID 2.0 tags:
    >     - Decode "Display Interface Features Data Block". Example in acer-xv273k* but it appears to be missing the "additional combinations count" byte.
    >     - Decode "ContainerID Data Block". Example in lg-ultrafine-5k*
    >     - Unknown DisplayID blocks are dumped as hex.
    > 
    > - Show DisplayID tag hex byte to make it possible to distinguish between DisplayID 1.3 and 2.0 spec blocks of the same name.
    > - Show DisplayID product type.
    > 
    > Signed-off-by: Joe van Tunen <joevt@xxxxxxx>
    > ---
    >  edid-decode.c | 525 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--
    >  1 file changed, 504 insertions(+), 21 deletions(-)
    > 
    > diff --git a/edid-decode.c b/edid-decode.c
    > index 2f2f1c5..29f8f88 100644
    > --- a/edid-decode.c
    > +++ b/edid-decode.c
    > @@ -55,6 +55,7 @@ static int did_detailed_timing = 0;
    >  static int has_name_descriptor = 0;
    >  static int has_serial_string = 0;
    >  static int has_ascii_string = 0;
    > +static int has_GP_ascii_string = 0;
    >  static int has_range_descriptor = 0;
    >  static int has_preferred_timing = 0;
    >  static int has_valid_checksum = 1;
    > @@ -64,6 +65,7 @@ static int has_valid_cvt = 1;
    >  static int has_valid_serial_number = 0;
    >  static int has_valid_serial_string = 0;
    >  static int has_valid_ascii_string = 0;
    > +static int has_valid_GP_ascii_string = 0;
    >  static int has_valid_name_descriptor = 0;
    >  static int has_valid_detailed_blocks = 0;
    >  static int has_valid_descriptor_ordering = 1;
    > @@ -2528,6 +2530,53 @@ static int parse_cta(const unsigned char *x)
    >         return ret;
    >  }
    >  
    > +
    > +static const char *feature_support_flags[] = {
    > +      "De-interlacing",
    > +      "Support ACP, ISRC1, or ISRC2packets",
    > +      "Fixed pixel format",
    > +      "Fixed timing",
    > +      "Power management (DPM)",
    > +      "Audio input override",
    > +      "Separate audio inputs provided",
    > +      "Audio support on video interface"
    > +};
    > +
    > +static void print_flag_lines(const char *indent, const char *label, unsigned char flag_byte, const char **flags) {
    > +      if (flag_byte) {
    > +                      printf("%s\n", label);
    > +                      for (int i = 0; i < 8; i++) {
    > +                                      if (flag_byte & (1<<i)) {
    > +                                                      printf("%s%s\n", indent, flags[i]);
    > +                                      }
    > +                      }
    > +      }
    > +}
    > +
    > +static void parse_displayid_parameters(const unsigned char *x) {
    > +      int revisionflags=x[1];
    > +      int len=x[2];
    > +      if (revisionflags) {
    > +                      printf("  Unexpected revision and flags (0x%02x != 0)\n", revisionflags);
    > +      }
    > +      if (len != 12) {
    > +                      printf("  Length is different than expected (%d != 12)\n", len);
    > +                      printf("  ");
    > +                      hex_block(x + 3, len);
    > +      } else {
    > +                      printf("  Image size: %.1f mm x %.1f mm\n", ((x[4]<<8) + x[3]) / 10.0, ((x[6]<<8) + x[5]) / 10.0);
    > +                      printf("  Pixels: %d x %d\n", (x[8]<<8) + x[7], (x[10]<<8) + x[9]);
    > +                      print_flag_lines("    ", "  Feature support flags:", x[11], feature_support_flags);
    > +
    > +                      if (x[12] != 0xff) {
    > +                                      printf("  Gamma: %.2f\n", ((x[12] + 100.0) / 100.0));
    > +                      }
    > +                      printf("  Aspect ratio: %.2f\n", ((x[13] + 100.0) / 100.0));
    > +                      printf("  Dynamic bpc native: %d\n", (x[14] & 0xf) + 1);
    > +                      printf("  Dynamic bpc overall: %d\n", ((x[14] >> 4) & 0xf) + 1);
    > +      } // else
    > +}
    > +
    >  static void parse_displayid_detailed_timing(const unsigned char *x)
    >  {
    >         unsigned ha, hbl, hso, hspw;
    > @@ -2713,18 +2762,343 @@ static const struct {
    >         {2560, 1600, 120, 16, 10, 203217, 552750, 1},
    >  };
    >  
    > +const char *displayid_vesa_dmt_timings[] = {
    > +      "640x350@85Hz",
    > +      "640x400@85Hz",
    > +      "720x400@85Hz",
    > +      "640x480@60Hz",
    > +      "640x480@72Hz",
    > +      "640x480@75Hz",
    > +      "640x480@85Hz",
    > +      "800x600@56Hz",
    > +      "800x600@60Hz",
    > +      "800x600@72Hz",
    > +      "800x600@75Hz",
    > +      "800x600@85Hz",
    > +      "800x600@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "848x480@60Hz",
    > +      "1024x768@43Hz (INT)",
    > +      "1024x768@60Hz",
    > +      "1024x768@70Hz",
    > +      "1024x768@75Hz",
    > +      "1024x768@85Hz",
    > +      "1024x768@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1152x864@75Hz",
    > +      "1280x768@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1280x768@60Hz",
    > +      "1280x768@75Hz",
    > +      "1280x768@85Hz",
    > +      "1280x768@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1280x800@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1280x800@60Hz",
    > +      "1280x800@75Hz",
    > +      "1280x800@85Hz",
    > +      "1280x800@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1280x960@60Hz",
    > +      "1280x960@85Hz",
    > +      "1280x960@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1280x1024@60Hz",
    > +      "1280x1024@75Hz",
    > +      "1280x1024@85Hz",
    > +      "1280x1024@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1360x768@60Hz",
    > +      "1360x768@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1400x1050@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1400x1050@60Hz",
    > +      "1400x1050@75Hz",
    > +      "1400x1050@85Hz",
    > +      "1400x1050@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1440x900@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1440x900@60Hz",
    > +      "1440x900@75Hz",
    > +      "1440x900@85Hz",
    > +      "1440x900@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1600x1200@60Hz",
    > +      "1600x1200@65Hz",
    > +      "1600x1200@70Hz",
    > +      "1600x1200@75Hz",
    > +      "1600x1200@85Hz",
    > +      "1600x1200@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1680x1050@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1680x1050@60Hz",
    > +      "1680x1050@75Hz",
    > +      "1680x1050@85Hz",
    > +      "1680x1050@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1792x1344@60Hz",
    > +      "1792x1344@75Hz",
    > +      "1792x1344@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1856x1392@60Hz",
    > +      "1856x1392@75Hz",
    > +      "1856x1392@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1920x1200@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1920x1200@60Hz",
    > +      "1920x1200@75Hz",
    > +      "1920x1200@85Hz",
    > +      "1920x1200@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "1920x1440@60Hz",
    > +      "1920x1440@75Hz",
    > +      "1920x1440@120Hz (RB)",
    > +      "2560x1600@60Hz (RB)",
    > +      "2560x1600@60Hz",
    > +      "2560x1600@75Hz",
    > +      "2560x1600@85Hz",
    > +      "2560x1600@120Hz (RB)",
    > +};
    
    Isn't this effectively the same as the displayid_vesa_dmt array?
    
    > +
    > +const char *displayid_cta_timings[] = {
    > +      "640x480p@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x480p@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x480p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080i@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x480i@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x480i@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x240p@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x240p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "2880x480i@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "2880x480i@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "2880x240p@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "2880x240p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1440x480p@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "1440x480p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720x576p@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x576p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080i@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x576i@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x576i@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x288p@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x288p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "2880x576i@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "2880x576i@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "2880x288p@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "2880x288p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1440x576p@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "1440x576p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@23.97/24Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@25Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@29.97/30Hz 16:9",
    > +      "2880x480p@59.94/60Hz 4:3",
    > +      "2880x480p@59.94/60Hz 16:9",
    > +      "2880x576p@50Hz 4:3",
    > +      "2880x576p@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080i@50Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080i@100Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@100Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720x576p@100Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x576p@100Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x576i@100Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x576i@100Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080i@119.88/120Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@119.88/120Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720x480p@119.88/120Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x480p@119.88/120Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x480i@119.88/120Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x480i@119.88/120Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720x576p@200Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x576p@200Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x576i@200Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x576i@200Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720x480p@239.76/240Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720x480p@239.76/240Hz 16:9",
    > +      "720(1440)x480i@239.76/240Hz 4:3",
    > +      "720(1440)x480i@239.76/240Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@23.97/24Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@25Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1280x720p@29.97/30Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@120Hz 16:9",
    > +      "1920x1080p@100Hz 16:9",
    > +};
    
    And this is the same as edid_cta_modes1[].
    
    > +
    > +static void parse_displayid_timing(const unsigned char *x, int expectedlen, const char** list)
    > +{
    > +      int revisionflags=x[1];
    > +      int len=x[2];
    > +      if (revisionflags) {
    > +                      printf("  Unexpected revision and flags (0x%02x != 0)\n", revisionflags);
    > +      }
    > +      if (len > expectedlen) {
    > +                      printf("  Length is greater than expected (%d > %d)\n", len, expectedlen);
    > +      } else if (len < expectedlen) {
    > +                      printf("  Length is less than expected (%d < %d)\n", len, expectedlen);
    > +      }
    > +      x += 3;
    > +      for (int i = 0; i < len * 8; i++) {
    > +                      if (x[i>>3] & (1<<(i&7))) {
    > +                                      if ((i>>3) < expectedlen) {
    > +                                                      printf("  %s\n", list[i]);
    > +                                      } else {
    > +                                                      printf("  #%d\n", i+1);
    > +                                      }
    > +                      }
    > +      }
    > +}
    > +
    > +static void parse_displayid_gp_string(const unsigned char *x)
    > +{
    > +      int revisionflags=x[1];
    > +      if (revisionflags) {
    > +                      printf("  Unexpected revision and flags (0x%02x != 0)\n", revisionflags);
    > +      }
    > +}
    > +
    > +static const char *bpc444[] = {"6", "8", "10", "12", "14", "16", NULL, NULL};
    > +static const char *bpc4xx[] = {"8", "10", "12", "14", "16", NULL, NULL, NULL};
    > +static const char *audiorates[] = {"32", "44.1", "48", NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL};
    > +
    > +static const char *colorspace_eotf_combinations[] = {
    > +      "sRGB",
    > +      "BT.601",
    > +      "BT.709/BT.1886",
    > +      "Adobe RGB",
    > +      "DCI-P3",
    > +      "BT.2020",
    > +      "BT.2020/SMPTE ST 2084"
    > +};
    > +
    > +static const char *colorspace_eotf_reserved[] = {NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL, NULL};
    > +
    > +static const char *colorspaces[] = {
    > +      "Undefined",
    > +      "sRGB",
    > +      "BT.601",
    > +      "BT.709",
    > +      "Adobe RGB",
    > +      "DCI-P3",
    > +      "BT.2020",
    > +      "Custom"
    > +};
    > +
    > +static const char *eotfs[] = {
    > +      "Undefined",
    > +      "sRGB",
    > +      "BT.601",
    > +      "BT.1886",
    > +      "Adobe RGB",
    > +      "DCI-P3",
    > +      "BT.2020",
    > +      "Gamma function",
    > +      "SMPTE ST 2084",
    > +      "Hybrid Log",
    > +      "Custom"
    > +};
    > +
    > +static void print_flags(const char *label, unsigned char flag_byte, const char **flags, int reverse)
    > +{
    > +      if (flag_byte) {
    > +                      printf("%s: ", label);
    > +                      int countflags = 0;
    > +                      for (int i = 0; i < 8; i++) {
    > +                                      if (flag_byte & (1<<(reverse?7-i:i))) {
    > +                                                      if (countflags)
    > +                                                                      printf(", ");
    > +                                                      if (flags[i])
    > +                                                                      printf("%s", flags[i]);
    > +                                                      else
    > +                                                                      printf("Undefined(%d)", i);
    > +                                                      countflags++;
    > +                                      }
    > +                      }
    > +                      printf("\n");
    > +      }
    > +}
    > +
    > +static void parse_displayid_interface_features(const unsigned char *x)
    > +{
    > +      int revisionflags=x[1];
    > +      int len=x[2];
    > +      if (revisionflags) {
    > +                      printf("  Unexpected revision and flags (0x%02x != 0)\n", revisionflags);
    > +      }
    > +      if (len < 9) {
    > +                      printf("  Length is less than expected (%d < 9)\n", len);
    > +                      printf("  ");
    > +                      hex_block(x + 3, len);
    > +      } else {
   > +                      print_flags("  Supported bpc for RGB encoding", x[3], bpc444, 0);
    > +                      print_flags("  Supported bpc for YCbCr 4:4:4 encoding", x[4], bpc444, 0);
    > +                      print_flags("  Supported bpc for YCbCr 4:2:2 encoding", x[5], bpc4xx, 0);
    > +                      print_flags("  Supported bpc for YCbCr 4:2:0 encoding", x[6], bpc4xx, 0);
    > +                      if (x[7])
    > +                                      printf("  Minimum pixel rate at which YCbCr 4:2:0 encoding is supported: %.3f MHz\n", 74.25 * x[7]);
    > +                      print_flags("  Supported audio capability and features (kHz)", x[8], audiorates, 1);
    > +                      print_flags("  Supported color space and EOTF standard combination 1", x[9], colorspace_eotf_combinations, 0);
    > +                      print_flags("  Supported color space and EOTF standard combination 2", x[10], colorspace_eotf_reserved, 0);
    > +                      int i = 0;
    > +                      if (len >= 9 && x[11] > 0) {
    > +                                      printf("  Supported color space and EOTF additional combinations:");
    > +                                      for (i = 1; i <= x[11]; i++) {
    > +                                                      if (i > 7) {
    > +                                                                      printf("\n  Number of additional color space and EOTF combinations (%d) is greater than allowed (7).", x[11]);
    > +                                                                      break;
    > +                                                      } else if (9 + i > len) {
    > +                                                                      printf("\n  Number of additional color space and EOTF combinations (%d) is too many to fit in block (%d).", x[11], len - 9);
    > +                                                                      break;
    > +                                                      }
    > +
    > +                                                      const char *colorspace = "Out of range";
    > +                                                      const char *eotf = "Out of range";
    > +                                                      int colorspace_index = (x[11 + i] >> 4) & 0xf;
    > +                                                      int eotf_index = x[11 + i] & 0xf;
    > +                                                      if (colorspace_index < sizeof(colorspaces) / sizeof(colorspaces[0])) {
    > +                                                                      colorspace = colorspaces[colorspace_index];
    > +                                                      }
    > +                                                      if (eotf_index < sizeof(eotfs) / sizeof(eotfs[0])) {
    > +                                                                      eotf = eotfs[eotf_index];
    > +                                                      }
    > +
    > +                                                      if (i > 1)
    > +                                                                      printf(", ");
    > +                                                      if (!strcmp(colorspace, eotf)) {
    > +                                                                      printf("%s", colorspace);
    > +                                                      } else {
    > +                                                                      printf("%s/%s", colorspace, eotf);
    > +                                                      }
    > +                                      } // for
    > +                                      printf("\n");
    > +                      } // x[11]
    > +                      if (len > 9 + i) {
    > +                                      printf("  Length is greater than expected (%d > %d)\n", len, 9 + i);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + 11 + i, len - 9 - i);
    > +                      } else if (len != 9 + i)  {
    > +                                      printf("  Length is unexpected (%d != %d)\n", len, 9 + i);
    > +                      }
    > +      }
    > +}
    > +
    > +static void parse_displayid_ContainerID(const unsigned char *x)
    > +{
    > +      int revisionflags=x[1];
    > +      int len=x[2];
    > +      if (revisionflags) {
    > +                      printf("  Unexpected revision and flags (0x%02x != 0)\n", revisionflags);
    > +      }
    > +      x += 3;
    > +      if (len != 16) {
    > +                      printf("  Length is unexpected (%d != 16)\n", len);
    > +                      printf("  ");
    > +                      hex_block(x, len);
    > +      } else {
    > +                      printf("  %02x%02x%02x%02x-%02x%02x-%02x%02x-%02x%02x-%02x%02x%02x%02x%02x%02x\n",x[0],x[1],x[2],x[3],x[4],x[5],x[6],x[7],x[8],x[9],x[10],x[11],x[12],x[13],x[14],x[15]);
    > +      }
    > +}
    > +
    >  static int parse_displayid(const unsigned char *x)
    >  {
    >         const unsigned char *orig = x;
    >         unsigned version = x[1];
    >         unsigned length = x[2];
    > +      unsigned producttype = x[3];
    >         unsigned ext_count = x[4];
    >         unsigned i;
    >  
    >         cur_block = "DisplayID";
    >  
    > -       printf("Length %u, version %u.%u, extension count %u\n",
    > -              length, version >> 4, version & 0xf, ext_count);
    > +      printf("Length %u, version %u.%u, type %u, extension count %u\n",
    > +             length, version >> 4, version & 0xf, producttype, ext_count);
    >  
    >         unsigned offset = 5;
    >         while (length > 0) {
    > @@ -2734,33 +3108,49 @@ static int parse_displayid(const unsigned char *x)
    >                         if (len == 0)
    >                                         break;
    >                         switch (tag) {
    > +                      
    > +                      // DisplayID 1.3:
    >                         case 0:
    > -                                       printf("Product ID Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Product ID Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 1:
    > -                                       printf("Display Parameters Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Display Parameters Block (%02Xh):\n", tag);
    > +                                      parse_displayid_parameters(x + offset);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 2:
    > -                                       printf("Color Characteristics Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Color Characteristics Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 3: {
    > -                                       printf("Type 1 Detailed Timings Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Type 1 Detailed Timings Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    >                                         for (i = 0; i < len / 20; i++) {
    >                                                         parse_displayid_detailed_timing(&x[offset + 3 + (i * 20)]);
    >                                         }
    >                                         break;
    >                         }
    >                         case 4:
    > -                                       printf("Type 2 Detailed Timings Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Type 2 Detailed Timings Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 5:
    > -                                       printf("Type 3 Short Timings Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Type 3 Short Timings Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 6:
    > -                                       printf("Type 4 DMT Timings Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Type 4 DMT Timings Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 7:
    > -                                       printf("Type 1 VESA DMT Timings Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Type 1 VESA DMT Timings Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      #if 0
    > +                                      parse_displayid_timing(x + offset, 10, displayid_vesa_dmt_timings);
    
    What is the reason for the #if 0?
    
    I now get a warning that displayid_vesa_dmt_timings is unused.
    
    > +                                      #else
    >                                         for (i = 0; i < min(len, 10) * 8; i++) {
    >                                                         if (x[offset + 3 + i / 8] & (1 << (i % 8))) {
    >                                                                         printf("  %ux%u%s@%uHz %s%u:%u HorFreq: %.3f kHz Clock: %.3f MHz\n",
    > @@ -2779,33 +3169,51 @@ static int parse_displayid(const unsigned char *x)
    >                                                                         max_pixclk_khz = max(max_pixclk_khz, displayid_vesa_dmt[i].pixclk_khz);
    >                                                         }
    >                                         }
    > +                                      #endif
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 8:
    > -                                       printf("CTA Timings Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("CTA Timings Block (%02Xh):\n", tag);
    > +                                      parse_displayid_timing(x + offset, 8, displayid_cta_timings);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 9:
    > -                                       printf("Video Timing Range Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Video Timing Range Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0xa:
    > -                                       printf("Product Serial Number Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Product Serial Number Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0xb:
    > -                                       printf("GP ASCII String Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("GP ASCII String Block (%02Xh): %s\n", tag, extract_string("GP ASCII String", x + offset + 3, &has_valid_GP_ascii_string, len));
    > +                                      has_GP_ascii_string = 1;
    > +                                      parse_displayid_gp_string(x + offset);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0xc:
    > -                                       printf("Display Device Data Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Display Device Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0xd:
    > -                                       printf("Interface Power Sequencing Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Interface Power Sequencing Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0xe:
    > -                                       printf("Transfer Characteristics Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Transfer Characteristics Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0xf:
    > -                                       printf("Display Interface Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Display Interface Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0x10:
    > -                                       printf("Stereo Display Interface Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Stereo Display Interface Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         case 0x12: {
    >                                         unsigned capabilities = x[offset + 3];
    > @@ -2817,7 +3225,7 @@ static int parse_displayid(const unsigned char *x)
    >                                         unsigned tile_height = x[offset + 9] | (x[offset + 10] << 8);
    >                                         unsigned pix_mult = x[offset + 11];
    >  
    > -                                       printf("Tiled Display Topology Block\n");
    > +                                      printf("Tiled Display Topology Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    >                                         printf("  Capabilities: 0x%08x\n", capabilities);
    >                                         printf("  Num horizontal tiles: %u Num vertical tiles: %u\n", num_h_tile + 1, num_v_tile + 1);
    >                                         printf("  Tile location: %u, %u\n", tile_h_location, tile_v_location);
    > @@ -2841,8 +3249,80 @@ static int parse_displayid(const unsigned char *x)
    >                                         }
    >                                         break;
    >                         }
    > +
    > +                      // DisplayID 2.0
    > +                      case 0x20:
    > +                                      printf("Product ID Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x21:
    > +                                      printf("Display Parameters Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x22:
    > +                                      printf("Type 7 Timing - Detailed Timing Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x23:
    > +                                      printf("Type 8 Timing - Enumerated Timing Code Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x24:
    > +                                      printf("Type 9 Timing - Formula-based Timing Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x25:
    > +                                      printf("Dynamic Video Timing Range Limits Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x26:
    > +                                      printf("Display Interface Features Data Block (%02Xh):\n", tag);
    > +                                      parse_displayid_interface_features(x + offset);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x27:
    > +                                      printf("Stereo Display Interface Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x28:
    > +                                      printf("Tiled Display Topology Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +                      case 0x29:
    > +                                      printf("ContainerID Data Block (%02Xh):\n", tag);
    > +                                      parse_displayid_ContainerID(x + offset);
    > +                                      break;
    > +
    > +                      // 2Ah .. 7Dh RESERVED for Additional VESA-defined Data Blocks
    > +
    > +                      case 0x7e: // DisplayID 2.0
    > +                      case 0x7f: // DisplayID 1.3
    > +                                      printf("Vendor-specific Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +
    > +                      // 7Fh .. 80h RESERVED
    > +
    > +                      case 0x81:
    > +                                      printf("CTA DisplayID Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    > +                                      break;
    > +
    > +                      // 82h .. FFh RESERVED
    > +                      
    >                         default:
    > -                                       printf("Unknown DisplayID Data Block 0x%x\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("Unknown DisplayID Data Block (%02Xh)\n", tag);
    > +                                      printf("  ");
    > +                                      hex_block(x + offset + 3, len);
    >                                         break;
    >                         }
    >                         length -= len + 3;
    > @@ -3687,6 +4167,7 @@ static int edid_from_file(const char *from_file, const char *to_file,
    >             !has_valid_range_descriptor ||
    >             (has_name_descriptor && !has_valid_name_descriptor) ||
    >             (has_serial_string && !has_valid_serial_string) ||
    > +                      (has_GP_ascii_string && !has_valid_GP_ascii_string) ||
    >             (has_ascii_string && !has_valid_ascii_string)) {
    >                         conformant = 0;
    >                         printf("EDID block does not conform:\n");
    > @@ -3709,6 +4190,8 @@ static int edid_from_file(const char *from_file, const char *to_file,
    >                                         printf("\tInvalid Monitor Name descriptor\n");
    >                         if (has_ascii_string && !has_valid_ascii_string)
    >                                         printf("\tInvalid ASCII string\n");
    > +                      if (has_GP_ascii_string && !has_valid_GP_ascii_string)
    > +                                      printf("\tInvalid GP ASCII string\n");
    >                         if (has_serial_string && !has_valid_serial_string)
    >                                         printf("\tInvalid serial string\n");
    >         }
    > 
    
    Regards,
    
                Hans
    







[Index of Archives]     [Linux Input]     [Video for Linux]     [Gstreamer Embedded]     [Mplayer Users]     [Linux USB Devel]     [Linux Audio Users]     [Linux Kernel]     [Linux SCSI]     [Yosemite Backpacking]

  Powered by Linux