On 2023-08-13 16:18, Alejandro Colomar wrote:
Hi Brian,
On 2023-08-13 22:47, Alejandro Colomar wrote:
Hi Brian,
On 2023-08-13 22:30, Brian Inglis wrote:
[...]
UI: I also noticed, while looking for tables to compare, that pages are ordered
by filename not like rpmvercmp/ls -v/RPM::VersionSort e.g ISO_8859-2 is after
ISO_8859-16 which may not be as expected.
Used rpmvercmp in last line of perl sub sortman and works as expected.
Hmm, I'll update the scripts/sortman script in the man-pages repo to tuse sort -V.
I intend that script (among Makefile code) to replace Deri's perl, as I don't
speak perl.
I didn't try your sort, but while implementing my own shell version of it, I
found that version sort wasn't good enough, as it makes some cases be worse. I
suggest you test it against my own script, and see if you get the same ordering.
If not, you'll need to tweak it. The most important thing is that _exit(2)
should go next to exit(2).
Now exit.2 and _Exit.2 are aliases to _exit.2, and exit(2) is not listed,
implemented, nor called by that wrapper, now exit_group(2) is "called" with
syscall(2), and that is also the only interface now for exit(2).
Here's what I did:
<https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/docs/man-pages/man-pages.git/commit/?id=aab14503ef101d918046aeaa941f226685fe7bf5>
#!/bin/sh
# Copyright 2023, Alejandro Colomar <alx@xxxxxxxxxx>
# SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-3.0-or-later
sed -E '/\/intro./ s/.*\.([[:digit:]])/\10\t&/' \
| sed -E '/\/intro./! s/.*\.([[:digit:]])\>/\11\t&/' \
| sed -E '/\/intro./! s/.*\.([[:digit:]])([[:alnum:]]+)/\12.\2\t&/' \
| sed -E ' s/\t(.*)/&\n\1/' \
| sed -E '/\t/ s/([^[:digit:]])[_-]([^[:digit:]])/\1\2/g' \
| sed -E '/\t/ s/[_-]/_/g' \
| sed -E '/\t/ {N;s/\n/\t/;}' \
| sort -fV \
| cut -f3;
Perl RPM::VersionSort rpmvercmp produces the desired order, ignoring leading
non-alphanumerics, treating all non-alphanumerics as field delimiters, treating
alphabetic and numeric strings as separate fields; see attached log.
--
Take care. Thanks, Brian Inglis Calgary, Alberta, Canada
La perfection est atteinte Perfection is achieved
non pas lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à ajouter not when there is no more to add
mais lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à retirer but when there is no more to cut
-- Antoine de Saint-Exupéryintro(1)
getent(1)
iconv(1)
ldd(1)
locale(1)
memusage(1)
memusagestat(1)
mtrace(1)
pldd(1)
time(1)
intro(2)
accept(2)
access(2)
acct(2)
add_key(2)
adjtimex(2)
alarm(2)
alloc_hugepages(2)
arch_prctl(2)
bdflush(2)
bind(2)
brk(2)
cacheflush(2)
capget(2)
chdir(2)
chmod(2)
chown(2)
chroot(2)
clock_getres(2)
clock_nanosleep(2)
clone(2)
close(2)
close_range(2)
connect(2)
copy_file_range(2)
create_module(2)
delete_module(2)
dup(2)
epoll_create(2)
epoll_ctl(2)
epoll_wait(2)
eventfd(2)
execve(2)
execveat(2)
_exit(2)
exit_group(2)
fallocate(2)
fanotify_init(2)
fanotify_mark(2)
fcntl(2)
flock(2)
fork(2)
fsync(2)
futex(2)
futimesat(2)
get_kernel_syms(2)
get_mempolicy(2)
get_robust_list(2)
getcpu(2)
getdents(2)
getdomainname(2)
getgid(2)
getgroups(2)
gethostname(2)
getitimer(2)
getpagesize(2)
getpeername(2)
getpid(2)
getpriority(2)
getrandom(2)
getresuid(2)
getrlimit(2)
getrusage(2)
getsid(2)
getsockname(2)
getsockopt(2)
gettid(2)
gettimeofday(2)
getuid(2)
getunwind(2)
getxattr(2)
idle(2)
init_module(2)
inotify_add_watch(2)
inotify_init(2)
inotify_rm_watch(2)
io_cancel(2)
io_destroy(2)
io_getevents(2)
io_setup(2)
io_submit(2)
ioctl(2)
ioctl_console(2)
ioctl_fat(2)
ioctl_ficlonerange(2)
ioctl_fideduperange(2)
ioctl_fslabel(2)
ioctl_getfsmap(2)
ioctl_iflags(2)
ioctl_ns(2)
ioctl_pipe(2)
ioctl_tty(2)
ioctl_userfaultfd(2)
ioperm(2)
iopl(2)
ioprio_set(2)
ipc(2)
kcmp(2)
kexec_load(2)
keyctl(2)
kill(2)
landlock_add_rule(2)
landlock_create_ruleset(2)
link(2)
listen(2)
listxattr(2)
_llseek(2)
lookup_dcookie(2)
lseek(2)
madvise(2)
mbind(2)
membarrier(2)
memfd_create(2)
memfd_secret(2)
migrate_pages(2)
mincore(2)
mkdir(2)
mknod(2)
mlock(2)
mmap(2)
mmap2(2)
modify_ldt(2)
mount(2)
mount_setattr(2)
move_pages(2)
mprotect(2)
mq_getsetattr(2)
mremap(2)
msgctl(2)
msgget(2)
MSGOP(2)
msync(2)
nanosleep(2)
nfsservctl(2)
nice(2)
open(2)
open_by_handle_at(2)
openat2(2)
outb(2)
pause(2)
pciconfig_read(2)
perf_event_open(2)
perfmonctl(2)
personality(2)
pidfd_getfd(2)
pidfd_open(2)
pidfd_send_signal(2)
pipe(2)
pivot_root(2)
pkey_alloc(2)
poll(2)
posix_fadvise(2)
prctl(2)
pread(2)
process_madvise(2)
process_vm_readv(2)
ptrace(2)
query_module(2)
quotactl(2)
read(2)
readahead(2)
readdir(2)
readlink(2)
readv(2)
reboot(2)
recv(2)
recvmmsg(2)
remap_file_pages(2)
removexattr(2)
rename(2)
request_key(2)
restart_syscall(2)
rmdir(2)
rt_sigqueueinfo(2)
s390_guarded_storage(2)
s390_pci_mmio_write(2)
s390_runtime_instr(2)
s390_sthyi(2)
sched_get_priority_max(2)
sched_rr_get_interval(2)
sched_setaffinity(2)
sched_setattr(2)
sched_setparam(2)
sched_setscheduler(2)
sched_yield(2)
seccomp(2)
seccomp_unotify(2)
select(2)
semctl(2)
semget(2)
semop(2)
send(2)
sendfile(2)
sendmmsg(2)
set_mempolicy(2)
set_thread_area(2)
set_tid_address(2)
seteuid(2)
setfsgid(2)
setfsuid(2)
setgid(2)
setns(2)
setpgid(2)
setresuid(2)
setreuid(2)
setsid(2)
setuid(2)
setup(2)
setxattr(2)
sgetmask(2)
shmctl(2)
shmget(2)
SHMOP(2)
shutdown(2)
sigaction(2)
sigaltstack(2)
signal(2)
signalfd(2)
sigpending(2)
sigprocmask(2)
sigreturn(2)
sigsuspend(2)
sigwaitinfo(2)
socket(2)
socketcall(2)
socketpair(2)
splice(2)
spu_create(2)
spu_run(2)
stat(2)
statfs(2)
statx(2)
stime(2)
subpage_prot(2)
swapon(2)
symlink(2)
sync(2)
sync_file_range(2)
_syscall(2)
syscall(2)
syscalls(2)
sysctl(2)
sysfs(2)
sysinfo(2)
syslog(2)
tee(2)
time(2)
timer_create(2)
timer_delete(2)
timer_getoverrun(2)
timer_settime(2)
timerfd_create(2)
times(2)
tkill(2)
truncate(2)
umask(2)
umount(2)
uname(2)
UNIMPLEMENTED(2)
unlink(2)
unshare(2)
uselib(2)
userfaultfd(2)
ustat(2)
utime(2)
utimensat(2)
vfork(2)
vhangup(2)
vm86(2)
vmsplice(2)
wait(2)
wait4(2)
write(2)
open_how(2type)
intro(3)
a64l(3)
abort(3)
abs(3)
acos(3)
acosh(3)
addseverity(3)
adjtime(3)
aio_cancel(3)
aio_error(3)
aio_fsync(3)
aio_init(3)
aio_read(3)
aio_return(3)
aio_suspend(3)
aio_write(3)
alloca(3)
arc4random(3)
argz_add(3)
asin(3)
asinh(3)
assert(3)
assert_perror(3)
atan2(3)
atan(3)
atanh(3)
atexit(3)
atoi(3)
backtrace(3)
basename(3)
bcmp(3)
bcopy(3)
bindresvport(3)
bsd_signal(3)
bsearch(3)
bstring(3)
bswap(3)
btowc(3)
btree(3)
BYTEORDER(3)
bzero(3)
cabs(3)
cacos(3)
cacosh(3)
canonicalize_file_name(3)
carg(3)
casin(3)
casinh(3)
catan(3)
catanh(3)
catgets(3)
catopen(3)
cbrt(3)
ccos(3)
ccosh(3)
ceil(3)
cexp2(3)
cexp(3)
cfree(3)
cimag(3)
CIRCLEQ(3)
clearenv(3)
clock(3)
clock_getcpuclockid(3)
clog2(3)
clog(3)
clog10(3)
closedir(3)
CMSG(3)
confstr(3)
conj(3)
copysign(3)
cos(3)
cosh(3)
cpow(3)
cproj(3)
creal(3)
crypt(3)
csin(3)
csinh(3)
csqrt(3)
ctan(3)
ctanh(3)
ctermid(3)
ctime(3)
daemon(3)
dbopen(3)
des_crypt(3)
difftime(3)
dirfd(3)
div(3)
dl_iterate_phdr(3)
dladdr(3)
dlerror(3)
dlinfo(3)
dlopen(3)
dlsym(3)
drand48(3)
drand48_r(3)
duplocale(3)
dysize(3)
ecvt(3)
ecvt_r(3)
encrypt(3)
end(3)
endian(3)
envz_add(3)
erfc(3)
err(3)
errno(3)
error(3)
ether_aton(3)
euidaccess(3)
exec(3)
exit(3)
exp2(3)
exp(3)
exp10(3)
expm1(3)
fabs(3)
fclose(3)
fcloseall(3)
fdim(3)
fenv(3)
ferror(3)
fexecve(3)
fflush(3)
ffs(3)
fgetc(3)
fgetgrent(3)
fgetpwent(3)
fgetwc(3)
fgetws(3)
fileno(3)
finite(3)
flockfile(3)
floor(3)
fma(3)
fmax(3)
fmemopen(3)
fmin(3)
fmod(3)
fmtmsg(3)
fnmatch(3)
fopen(3)
fopencookie(3)
fpclassify(3)
fpurge(3)
fputwc(3)
fputws(3)
fread(3)
frexp(3)
fseek(3)
fseeko(3)
ftime(3)
ftok(3)
fts(3)
ftw(3)
futimes(3)
fwide(3)
gamma(3)
gcvt(3)
_Generic(3)
get_nprocs(3)
get_phys_pages(3)
getaddrinfo(3)
getaddrinfo_a(3)
getauxval(3)
getcontext(3)
getcwd(3)
getdate(3)
getdirentries(3)
getdtablesize(3)
getentropy(3)
getenv(3)
getfsent(3)
getgrent(3)
getgrent_r(3)
getgrnam(3)
getgrouplist(3)
gethostbyname(3)
gethostid(3)
getifaddrs(3)
getipnodebyname(3)
getline(3)
getloadavg(3)
getlogin(3)
getmntent(3)
getnameinfo(3)
getnetent(3)
getnetent_r(3)
getopt(3)
getpass(3)
getprotoent(3)
getprotoent_r(3)
getpt(3)
getpw(3)
getpwent(3)
getpwent_r(3)
getpwnam(3)
getrpcent(3)
getrpcent_r(3)
getrpcport(3)
gets(3)
getservent(3)
getservent_r(3)
getspnam(3)
getsubopt(3)
getttyent(3)
getusershell(3)
getutent(3)
getutmp(3)
getw(3)
getwchar(3)
glob(3)
gnu_get_libc_version(3)
grantpt(3)
group_member(3)
gsignal(3)
hash(3)
hsearch(3)
hypot(3)
iconv(3)
iconv_close(3)
iconv_open(3)
if_nameindex(3)
if_nametoindex(3)
ilogb(3)
index(3)
inet(3)
inet_net_pton(3)
inet_ntop(3)
inet_pton(3)
initgroups(3)
insque(3)
isalpha(3)
isatty(3)
isfdtype(3)
isgreater(3)
iswalnum(3)
iswalpha(3)
iswblank(3)
iswcntrl(3)
iswctype(3)
iswdigit(3)
iswgraph(3)
iswlower(3)
iswprint(3)
iswpunct(3)
iswspace(3)
iswupper(3)
iswxdigit(3)
j0(3)
key_setsecret(3)
killpg(3)
ldexp(3)
lgamma(3)
lio_listio(3)
localeconv(3)
log1p(3)
log2(3)
log(3)
log10(3)
logb(3)
login(3)
lrint(3)
lround(3)
lsearch(3)
lseek64(3)
makecontext(3)
makedev(3)
mallinfo(3)
malloc(3)
malloc_get_state(3)
__malloc_hook(3)
malloc_info(3)
malloc_stats(3)
malloc_trim(3)
malloc_usable_size(3)
mallopt(3)
matherr(3)
MAX(3)
MB_CUR_MAX(3)
MB_LEN_MAX(3)
mblen(3)
mbrlen(3)
mbrtowc(3)
mbsinit(3)
mbsnrtowcs(3)
mbsrtowcs(3)
mbstowcs(3)
mbtowc(3)
mcheck(3)
memccpy(3)
memchr(3)
memcmp(3)
memcpy(3)
memfrob(3)
memmem(3)
memmove(3)
mempcpy(3)
memset(3)
mkdtemp(3)
mkfifo(3)
mkstemp(3)
mktemp(3)
mpool(3)
mq_close(3)
mq_getattr(3)
mq_notify(3)
mq_open(3)
mq_receive(3)
mq_send(3)
mq_unlink(3)
mtrace(3)
nan(3)
netlink(3)
newlocale(3)
nextafter(3)
nextup(3)
nl_langinfo(3)
ntp_gettime(3)
on_exit(3)
open_memstream(3)
opendir(3)
openpty(3)
perror(3)
popen(3)
posix_fallocate(3)
posix_madvise(3)
posix_memalign(3)
posix_openpt(3)
posix_spawn(3)
pow(3)
pow10(3)
powerof2(3)
__ppc_get_timebase(3)
__ppc_set_ppr_med(3)
__ppc_yield(3)
profil(3)
program_invocation_name(3)
psignal(3)
pthread_atfork(3)
pthread_attr_init(3)
pthread_attr_setaffinity_np(3)
pthread_attr_setdetachstate(3)
pthread_attr_setguardsize(3)
pthread_attr_setinheritsched(3)
pthread_attr_setschedparam(3)
pthread_attr_setschedpolicy(3)
pthread_attr_setscope(3)
pthread_attr_setsigmask_np(3)
pthread_attr_setstack(3)
pthread_attr_setstackaddr(3)
pthread_attr_setstacksize(3)
pthread_cancel(3)
pthread_cleanup_push(3)
pthread_cleanup_push_defer_np(3)
pthread_create(3)
pthread_detach(3)
pthread_equal(3)
pthread_exit(3)
pthread_getattr_default_np(3)
pthread_getattr_np(3)
pthread_getcpuclockid(3)
pthread_join(3)
pthread_kill(3)
pthread_kill_other_threads_np(3)
pthread_mutex_consistent(3)
pthread_mutexattr_getpshared(3)
pthread_mutexattr_init(3)
pthread_mutexattr_setrobust(3)
pthread_rwlockattr_setkind_np(3)
pthread_setaffinity_np(3)
pthread_setcancelstate(3)
pthread_setconcurrency(3)
pthread_setname_np(3)
pthread_setschedparam(3)
pthread_setschedprio(3)
pthread_sigmask(3)
pthread_sigqueue(3)
pthread_spin_init(3)
pthread_spin_lock(3)
pthread_testcancel(3)
pthread_tryjoin_np(3)
pthread_yield(3)
ptsname(3)
putenv(3)
putgrent(3)
putpwent(3)
puts(3)
putwchar(3)
qecvt(3)
qsort(3)
raise(3)
rand(3)
random(3)
random_r(3)
rcmd(3)
re_comp(3)
readdir(3)
readdir_r(3)
realpath(3)
recno(3)
regex(3)
remainder(3)
remove(3)
remquo(3)
resolver(3)
rewinddir(3)
rexec(3)
rint(3)
round(3)
roundup(3)
rpc(3)
rpmatch(3)
rtime(3)
rtnetlink(3)
scalb(3)
scalbln(3)
scandir(3)
sched_getcpu(3)
seekdir(3)
sem_close(3)
sem_destroy(3)
sem_getvalue(3)
sem_init(3)
sem_open(3)
sem_post(3)
sem_unlink(3)
sem_wait(3)
setaliasent(3)
setenv(3)
__setfpucw(3)
setjmp(3)
setlocale(3)
setlogmask(3)
setnetgrent(3)
shm_open(3)
siginterrupt(3)
signbit(3)
significand(3)
sigpause(3)
sigqueue(3)
sigset(3)
SIGSETOPS(3)
sigvec(3)
sigwait(3)
sin(3)
sincos(3)
sinh(3)
sleep(3)
sockatmark(3)
sqrt(3)
STAILQ(3)
static_assert(3)
statvfs(3)
stdarg(3)
stdin(3)
stdio(3)
stdio_ext(3)
stpncpy(3)
strcasecmp(3)
strchr(3)
strcmp(3)
strcoll(3)
strcpy(3)
strdup(3)
strerror(3)
strfmon(3)
strfromd(3)
strfry(3)
strftime(3)
string(3)
strlen(3)
strncat(3)
strnlen(3)
strpbrk(3)
strptime(3)
strsep(3)
strsignal(3)
strspn(3)
strstr(3)
strtod(3)
strtoimax(3)
strtok(3)
strtol(3)
strtoul(3)
strverscmp(3)
strxfrm(3)
swab(3)
syslog(3)
system(3)
sysv_signal(3)
TAILQ(3)
tan(3)
tanh(3)
tcgetpgrp(3)
tcgetsid(3)
telldir(3)
tempnam(3)
termios(3)
tgamma(3)
timegm(3)
timeradd(3)
tmpfile(3)
tmpnam(3)
toascii(3)
toupper(3)
towctrans(3)
towlower(3)
towupper(3)
trunc(3)
tsearch(3)
ttyname(3)
ttyslot(3)
tzset(3)
ualarm(3)
ulimit(3)
undocumented(3)
ungetwc(3)
unlocked_stdio(3)
unlockpt(3)
updwtmp(3)
uselocale(3)
usleep(3)
wcpcpy(3)
wcpncpy(3)
wcrtomb(3)
wcscasecmp(3)
wcscat(3)
wcschr(3)
wcscmp(3)
wcscpy(3)
wcscspn(3)
wcsdup(3)
wcslen(3)
wcsncasecmp(3)
wcsncat(3)
wcsncmp(3)
wcsncpy(3)
wcsnlen(3)
wcsnrtombs(3)
wcspbrk(3)
wcsrchr(3)
wcsrtombs(3)
wcsspn(3)
wcsstr(3)
wcstoimax(3)
wcstok(3)
wcstombs(3)
wcswidth(3)
wctob(3)
wctomb(3)
wctrans(3)
wctype(3)
wcwidth(3)
wmemchr(3)
wmemcmp(3)
wmemcpy(3)
wmemmove(3)
wmemset(3)
wordexp(3)
xdr(3)
y0(3)
EOF(3const)
EXIT_SUCCESS(3const)
NULL(3const)
printf.h(3head)
sysexits.h(3head)
aiocb(3type)
blkcnt_t(3type)
blksize_t(3type)
cc_t(3type)
clock_t(3type)
clockid_t(3type)
dev_t(3type)
div_t(3type)
double_t(3type)
epoll_event(3type)
fenv_t(3type)
FILE(3type)
id_t(3type)
intmax_t(3type)
intN_t(3type)
intptr_t(3type)
iovec(3type)
itimerspec(3type)
lconv(3type)
mode_t(3type)
off_t(3type)
ptrdiff_t(3type)
size_t(3type)
sockaddr(3type)
stat(3type)
time_t(3type)
timer_t(3type)
timespec(3type)
timeval(3type)
tm(3type)
va_list(3type)
void(3type)
intro(4)
cciss(4)
console_codes(4)
cpuid(4)
dsp56k(4)
fd(4)
full(4)
fuse(4)
hd(4)
hpsa(4)
initrd(4)
lirc(4)
loop(4)
lp(4)
mem(4)
mouse(4)
msr(4)
null(4)
pts(4)
ram(4)
random(4)
rtc(4)
sd(4)
sk98lin(4)
smartpqi(4)
st(4)
tty(4)
ttyS(4)
vcs(4)
veth(4)
wavelan(4)
intro(5)
acct(5)
charmap(5)
core(5)
dir_colors(5)
ELF(5)
erofs(5)
filesystems(5)
ftpusers(5)
group(5)
hosts(5)
hosts.equiv(5)
issue(5)
locale(5)
motd(5)
networks(5)
nologin(5)
nss(5)
passwd(5)
proc(5)
protocols(5)
repertoiremap(5)
rpc(5)
securetty(5)
services(5)
shells(5)
slabinfo(5)
sysfs(5)
termcap(5)
tmpfs(5)
ttytype(5)
tzfile(5)
utmp(5)
intro(6)
intro(7)
address_families(7)
AIO(7)
ARMSCII-8(7)
arp(7)
ascii(7)
attributes(7)
boot(7)
bootparam(7)
BPF-HELPERS(7)
Capabilities(7)
cgroup_namespaces(7)
cgroups(7)
charsets(7)
complex(7)
cp1251(7)
cp1252(7)
cpuset(7)
credentials(7)
ddp(7)
environ(7)
epoll(7)
fanotify(7)
feature_test_macros(7)
fifo(7)
futex(7)
glob(7)
hier(7)
hostname(7)
icmp(7)
inode(7)
inotify(7)
ip(7)
ipc_namespaces(7)
ipv6(7)
ISO_8859-1(7)
ISO_8859-2(7)
ISO_8859-3(7)
ISO_8859-4(7)
ISO_8859-5(7)
ISO_8859-6(7)
ISO_8859-7(7)
ISO_8859-8(7)
ISO_8859-9(7)
ISO_8859-10(7)
ISO_8859-11(7)
ISO_8859-13(7)
ISO_8859-14(7)
ISO_8859-15(7)
ISO_8859-16(7)
kernel_lockdown(7)
keyrings(7)
KOI8-R(7)
KOI8-U(7)
Landlock(7)
libc(7)
locale(7)
mailaddr(7)
man-pages(7)
man(7)
math_error(7)
mount_namespaces(7)
mq_overview(7)
namespaces(7)
netdevice(7)
netlink(7)
network_namespaces(7)
nptl(7)
numa(7)
operator(7)
packet(7)
path_resolution(7)
persistent-keyring(7)
pid_namespaces(7)
pipe(7)
pkeys(7)
posixoptions(7)
process-keyring(7)
pthreads(7)
pty(7)
queue(7)
random(7)
raw(7)
regex(7)
rtnetlink(7)
sched(7)
sem_overview(7)
session-keyring(7)
shm_overview(7)
sigevent(7)
signal-safety(7)
signal(7)
sock_diag(7)
socket(7)
spufs(7)
standards(7)
string_copying(7)
SUFFIXES(7)
symlink(7)
system_data_types(7)
sysvipc(7)
tcp(7)
termio(7)
thread-keyring(7)
time(7)
time_namespaces(7)
udp(7)
udplite(7)
unicode(7)
units(7)
UNIX(7)
uri(7)
user-keyring(7)
user_namespaces(7)
user-session-keyring(7)
UTF-8(7)
uts_namespaces(7)
vDSO(7)
vsock(7)
x25(7)
xattr(7)
intro(8)
iconvconfig(8)
ld.so(8)
ldconfig(8)
nscd(8)
sln(8)
tzselect(8)
zdump(8)
zic(8)
