On Thu, 1 Dec 2022, Shuah Khan wrote: > On 11/30/22 15:22, Joe Lawrence wrote: > > On 7/15/22 10:45 AM, Petr Mladek wrote: > >> On Fri 2022-07-01 16:13:50, Shuah Khan wrote: > >>> On 7/1/22 1:48 AM, Miroslav Benes wrote: > >>>> On Thu, 30 Jun 2022, Shuah Khan wrote: > >>>>> > >>>>> Sorry Nack on this. Let's not add modules under selftests. Any usage of > >>>>> module_init() > >>>>> doesn't belong under selftests. > >>> > >>> Yes I did and after reviewing and thinking about it some more, I decided > >>> this > >>> is the right direction go down on. > >> > >> Do you have some particular reason why building modules in selftests > >> directory might cause problems, please? > >> > > My reasons are that with this change module_init() propagates out of > strictly kernel space and now is in selftests which are user-space. > Any changes to this interface will be tied to user-space change. I do not understand this (have not had a cup of tea yet). module_init() is defined in include/linux/module.h. It is API. Every kernel module, in-tree or out-of-tree, uses it. There is only one usage of module_init() in Marcos's patch. In a kernel module, in tools/ subdirectory yes. If there is a change to module_init, it might need editing all the call sites, yes. That is inherent. > This is my main concern. That is reason why I still ask the question > about why is it necessary to make this change other than self-contained > sources? I will quote myself from an earlier email in the thread which you have not replied to... " My main question is different though. As Marcos mentioned before, we would like to have our tests really flexible and a possibility to prepare and load different live patch modules based on a template is a part of it. What is your proposal regarding this? I can imagine having a template in lib/livepatch/ which would not be compilable and a script in tools/testing/selftests/livepatch/ would copy it many times, amend the copies (meaning parameters would be filled in with sed or the code would be changed), compile them and load them. But this sounds horrible to me, especially when compared to Marcos' approach in this patch set which is quite straightforward. " Thank you Miroslav
