On Fri, Oct 12, 2018 at 04:24:08PM +0200, Benjamin Tissoires wrote: > Since v4.18, we unconditionally switch the I2C capable touchpads over I2C. > In the model I had (a pre-prod t480s I guess), the touchpad was behaving > fine. > However, it occurs that later production models don't expose the clickpad > information from I2C. The Windows driver gets all the information from PS/2 > so we should do the same. > > The situation is even worse for the P52. Once of the query parameter function > fails, which means the touchpad doesn't even probe. This effectively kills > the touchpad, which is less than ideal. > > Dmitry, I am not sure if we should take those for stable in v4.18+. > I'd like to, but given the series is 5 patches, I don't know if this > will be acceptable. > We could revert in stable df077237cf55928f5 but that would mean > distributions will have to revert the revert if they want to provide > the I2C behavior. > > So, regarding stable: your call :) Heh ;) I think we have to fix it at least in 4.19 stable train. How about we merge it normally into 4.20, and let it cook there for a while. If there is no issues, then we can send it to 4.19 stable manually. How does this sound? Thanks. -- Dmitry
