On Mo, 11.12.23 17:03, Eric Curtin (ecurtin@xxxxxxxxxx) wrote: > A generic approach is hard, I think it's worth discussing which type of boots > you should actually care about milliseconds of performance for. It would be nice > if we had an init system that contained the binary data to do the minimum for > standard Fedora, Debian installs and everything else was an extension whether > that's sysexts, dlopen, a new binary to execute etc. > > If the network is ingrained in your boot stack like this, I'm > guessing you probably don't care about boot performance. Uh, I am not sure that's really true. People boot up VMs on demand, based on network traffic. They sure care about latency and boot times. I mean people care about firecracker and these things precisely because it brings the of off-to-IP to a minimum. > Automotive has an expectation for really fast boots, like 2 seconds, in standard > desktops installs there's some expectation as you interface directly > with a human, > but for other installs how much expectation is there? AFAIR in particular in cars there's quite som functionality you probaly want to move very early in boot. Which yells to me that you want a service manager super early. Which again suggests to me that the first initrd that runs should probably already cover that. If I were you I'd probably focus on a design like this: ship a basic systemd in an initrd. Complete enough to find the harddisk, and to run the other services that are absolutely necessary this early. Then, once you found the disk, look for sysext images on it, and apply them all on top of the initrd's root fs you are already running with. Never transition anywhere else. The try to optimize the initrd a bit by making it an erofs/memmap thing and so on. And make sure the initrd only contains stuff you always need, so that reading it all into memory is necessary anyway, and hence any approach that tries to run even the initrd off a disk image won't be necessary becuase you need to read everything anyway. Lennart -- Lennart Poettering, Berlin
