On Fri, Oct 04, 2024 at 08:18:11AM +0200, Javier González wrote: >> And for anyone who followed the previous discussions of the patches >> none of this should been new, each point has been made at least three >> times before. > > Looking at the work you and Hans have been doing on XFS, it seems you > have been successful at mapping the semantics of the temperature to > zones (which has no semantics, just as FDP). > > What is the difference between the mapping in zones and for FDP? Probably not much, except for all the pitfalls in the FDP not quite hint not madatory design. > The whole point is using an existing interface to cover the use-case of > people wanting hints in block. And that's fine. And that point all the way back for month is that doing a complete dumb mapping in the driver for that is fundamentally wrong. Kanchan's previous series did about 50% of the work to get it rid, but then everyone dropped dead and played politics.
