[Bug 217965] ext4(?) regression since 6.5.0 on sata hdd

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=217965

--- Comment #22 from Eyal Lebedinsky (bugzilla@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx) ---
I now ran a test on 6.4.15. I copied a segment of the tree I have issues with.
    7.2GB in 77,972 files.

It took just over 9 minutes to sync the drain the dirty cache, and the array
run like this
(I am watching the kB_wrtn/s column):

         Device             tps    kB_read/s    kB_wrtn/s    kB_dscd/s   
kB_read    kB_wrtn    kB_dscd
18:15:01 md127           423.00         4.00      7001.20         0.00        
40      70012          0
18:15:11 md127           112.30        14.80      9689.60         0.00       
148      96896          0
18:15:21 md127            28.70         3.60       964.80         0.00        
36       9648          0
18:15:31 md127           321.90         4.00      1340.40         0.00        
40      13404          0
18:15:41 md127            18.20         0.00       123.20         0.00         
0       1232          0
18:15:51 md127            26.80        10.00      2062.00         0.00       
100      20620          0
18:16:01 md127             2.60         0.00        56.40         0.00         
0        564          0
18:16:11 md127             2.80         0.00        82.40         0.00         
0        824          0
18:16:21 md127             6.10         0.00       150.80         0.00         
0       1508          0
18:16:31 md127            86.00        16.80      4978.00         0.00       
168      49780          0
18:16:41 md127            48.90        10.80      4505.60         0.00       
108      45056          0
18:16:51 md127            36.10         6.80      1498.00         0.00        
68      14980          0
18:17:01 md127             3.20         0.40        64.40         0.00         
4        644          0
18:17:11 md127             3.40         0.80        84.80         0.00         
8        848          0
18:17:21 md127             3.70         0.80       283.60         0.00         
8       2836          0
18:17:31 md127            32.90         6.00      1950.00         0.00        
60      19500          0
18:17:41 md127           907.50        24.00     15638.40         0.00       
240     156384          0
18:17:51 md127           698.00         9.60     10476.40         0.00        
96     104764          0
18:18:01 md127           146.80         0.40      4796.00         0.00         
4      47960          0
18:18:11 md127           163.00         0.80      1328.80         0.00         
8      13288          0
18:18:21 md127           149.50         1.20      1140.00         0.00        
12      11400          0
18:18:31 md127            46.50         1.60       545.20         0.00        
16       5452          0
18:18:41 md127           335.90        14.40      9770.00         0.00       
144      97700          0
18:18:51 md127           119.90         4.40      3868.80         0.00        
44      38688          0
18:19:01 md127           315.70        25.60     11422.80         0.00       
256     114228          0
18:19:11 md127           285.80         1.20      4142.40         0.00        
12      41424          0
18:19:21 md127           239.00         4.40      3888.00         0.00        
44      38880          0
18:19:31 md127           116.30         1.20      1752.80         0.00        
12      17528          0
18:19:41 md127           166.60         8.00      8886.00         0.00        
80      88860          0
18:19:51 md127           357.20         5.60      6146.80         0.00        
56      61468          0
18:20:01 md127           118.10         1.20      1670.40         0.00        
12      16704          0
18:20:11 md127            66.00         6.40       802.80         0.00        
64       8028          0
18:20:21 md127           139.40         4.40      1641.20         0.00        
44      16412          0
18:20:31 md127            44.40         2.40       632.40         0.00        
24       6324          0
18:20:41 md127           183.50        13.60      4048.40         0.00       
136      40484          0
18:20:51 md127           114.40        28.40      8346.40         0.00       
284      83464          0
18:21:01 md127           152.20        27.20     15576.00         0.00       
272     155760          0
18:21:11 md127            75.30         1.60      1146.40         0.00        
16      11464          0
18:21:21 md127           236.20        18.40     13491.20         0.00       
184     134912          0
18:21:31 md127           226.70         3.60      3237.60         0.00        
36      32376          0
18:21:41 md127           152.70         4.00      2048.00         0.00        
40      20480          0
18:21:51 md127            92.10         7.60      1907.20         0.00        
76      19072          0
18:22:01 md127           142.50         8.00      1921.60         0.00        
80      19216          0
18:22:11 md127           137.30         5.60      2307.60         0.00        
56      23076          0
18:22:21 md127           124.10         6.00      1511.20         0.00        
60      15112          0
18:22:31 md127           105.90         4.00      1888.80         0.00        
40      18888          0
18:22:41 md127           166.30         2.00      2073.20         0.00        
20      20732          0
18:22:51 md127           649.90         6.80     10615.20         0.00        
68     106152          0
18:23:01 md127          1253.70         8.80    175698.40         0.00        
88    1756984          0
18:23:11 md127            88.40         2.00     66840.40         0.00        
20     668404          0
18:23:21 md127             0.00         0.00         0.00         0.00         
0          0          0

Is writing at a few MB/s reasonable for an array with disks that can top
200MB/s?
Note the burst at the end when a significant chunk of the data was written out.

Now running on 6.5.10 I see a very different story:

         Device             tps    kB_read/s    kB_wrtn/s    kB_dscd/s   
kB_read    kB_wrtn    kB_dscd
18:45:53 md127             2.60         0.00        10.40         0.00         
0        104          0
18:46:03 md127             5.40         0.00        21.60         0.00         
0        216          0
18:46:13 md127             5.40         0.00        21.60         0.00         
0        216          0
18:46:23 md127             5.30         0.00        21.60         0.00         
0        216          0
18:46:33 md127             5.20         0.00        20.80         0.00         
0        208          0
18:46:43 md127             5.30         0.00        23.60         0.00         
0        236          0
18:46:53 md127             5.10         0.00        44.00         0.00         
0        440          0
18:47:03 md127             2.70         0.00        21.60         0.00         
0        216          0
18:47:13 md127             5.30         0.00        26.80         0.00         
0        268          0
18:47:23 md127             5.40         0.00        25.20         0.00         
0        252          0
18:47:33 md127             5.20         0.00        21.60         0.00         
0        216          0
18:47:43 md127             5.30         0.00        21.20         0.00         
0        212          0
18:47:53 md127             5.30         0.00        22.40         0.00         
0        224          0
18:48:03 md127             5.40         0.00        24.00         0.00         
0        240          0
18:48:13 md127             2.60         0.00        11.20         0.00         
0        112          0
18:48:23 md127             5.30         0.00        22.40         0.00         
0        224          0
18:48:33 md127             5.30         0.00        23.20         0.00         
0        232          0
18:48:43 md127             5.20         0.00        24.40         0.00         
0        244          0
18:48:53 md127             5.30         0.00        22.00         0.00         
0        220          0
18:49:03 md127             6.20         3.60        23.20         0.00        
36        232          0
18:49:13 md127             3.40         0.00        20.80         0.00         
0        208          0
18:49:23 md127             5.20         0.00        20.80         0.00         
0        208          0
18:49:33 md127             5.30         0.00        22.00         0.00         
0        220          0
18:49:43 md127             5.30         0.00        21.60         0.00         
0        216          0
18:49:53 md127             5.20         0.00        33.20         0.00         
0        332          0

I expect this to take much longer to complete, possibly hours (20% drained in
the last 30m).

In both cases the flusher thread was running at 100%CPU.

I do have the full logs though.

HTH

-- 
You may reply to this email to add a comment.

You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching the assignee of the bug.




[Index of Archives]     [Reiser Filesystem Development]     [Ceph FS]     [Kernel Newbies]     [Security]     [Netfilter]     [Bugtraq]     [Linux FS]     [Yosemite National Park]     [MIPS Linux]     [ARM Linux]     [Linux Security]     [Linux RAID]     [Samba]     [Device Mapper]     [Linux Media]

  Powered by Linux