Pavel Machek wrote:
On Mon 2009-08-24 16:22:22, Zan Lynx wrote:
Ric Wheeler wrote:
Pavel Machek wrote:
Degraded MD RAID5 does not work by design; whole stripe will be
damaged on powerfail or reset or kernel bug, and ext3 can not cope
with that kind of damage. [I don't see why statistics should be
neccessary for that; the same way we don't need statistics to see that
ext2 needs fsck after powerfail.]
Pavel
What you are describing is a double failure and RAID5 is not double
failure tolerant regardless of the file system type....
Are you sure he isn't talking about how RAID must write all the data
chunks to make a complete stripe and if there is a power-loss, some of
the chunks may be written and some may not?
As I read Pavel's point he is saying that the incomplete write can be
detected by the incorrect parity chunk, but degraded RAID-5 has no
working parity chunk so the incomplete write would go undetected.
Yep.
I know this is a RAID failure mode. However, I actually thought this was
a problem even for a intact RAID-5. AFAIK, RAID-5 does not generally
read the complete stripe and perform verification unless that is
requested, because doing so would hurt performance and lose the entire
point of the RAID-5 rotating parity blocks.
Not sure; is not RAID expected to verify the array after unclean
shutdown?
Pavel
Not usually - that would take multiple hours of verification, roughly
equivalent to doing a RAID rebuild since you have to read each sector of
every drive (although you would do this at full speed if the array was
offline, not throttled like we do with rebuilds).
That is part of the thing that scrubbing can do.
Note that once you find a bad bit of data, it is really useful to be
able to map that back into a humanly understandable object/repair
action. For example, map the bad data range back to metadata which would
translate into a fsck run or a list of impacted files or directories....
Ric
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-ext4" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
