On Tue, 23 Jul 2013, Tomasz Figa wrote: > > If you want to keep the phy struct completely separate from the board > > file, there's an easy way to do it. Let's say the board file knows > > about N different PHYs in the system. Then you define an array of N > > pointers to phys: > > > > struct phy *(phy_address[N]); > > > > In the platform data for both PHY j and its controller, store > > &phy_address[j]. The PHY provider passes this cookie to phy_create: > > > > cookie = pdev->dev.platform_data; > > ret = phy_create(phy, cookie); > > > > and phy_create simply stores: *cookie = phy. The PHY consumer does > > much the same the same thing: > > > > cookie = pdev->dev.platform_data; > > phy = phy_get(cookie); > > > > phy_get returns *cookie if it isn't NULL, or an ERR_PTR otherwise. > > OK, this can work. Again, just technically, because it's rather ugly. There's no reason the phy_address things have to be arrays. A separate individual pointer for each PHY would work just as well. > Where would you want to have those phy_address arrays stored? There are no > board files when booting with DT. Not even saying that you don't need to > use any hacky schemes like this when you have DT that nicely specifies > relations between devices. If everybody agrees DT has a nice scheme for specifying relations between devices, why not use that same scheme in the PHY core? > Anyway, board file should not be considered as a method to exchange data > between drivers. It should be used only to pass data from it to drivers, > not the other way. Ideally all data in a board file should be marked as > const and __init and dropped after system initialization. The phy_address things don't have to be defined or allocated in the board file; they could be set up along with the platform data. In any case, this was simply meant to be a suggestion to show that it is relatively easy to do what you need without using name or ID strings. Alan Stern -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-doc" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html