On 07/18/2013 10:07 AM, Christian Ruppert wrote:
...
> Well, perhaps my definition of "inside"/"outside" pins was not quite
> clear: The pin groups define the set of (kernel internal) pin numbers of
> "outside" pins which are used by pin controller to map a given
> interface. Inside pins are not numbered and the inside interfaces are
> only used to determine which outside pins are part of the same group
> (namely those for which the pin controller hardware provides a mux
> connection to the same inside interface):
>
> 4
> 4 /|--/-- SPI
> PINS[0..3] --/--|| 4
> \|--/-- GPIO[0..3]
>
> 4
> PINS[4..7] -----/------ GPIO[4..7]
>
> 2
> 2 /|--/-- I2C
> PINS[8..9] --/--|| 2
> \|--/-- GPIO[8..9]
>
> Pins 0..3 are in the SPI group because on the "inside" they can be muxed
> to the SPI interface.
> Pins 8..9 are in the I2C group because on the "inside" they can be muxed
> to the I2C interface.
> Pins 0..9 are in the GPIO group because on the "inside" they can be
> muxed to the GPIO controller.
>
> All pin numbers are relative to the "outside", however, or conflict
> management would not be possible. I hope this is more understandable
> than my previous explanations.
> Both muxes are controlled by the same register. In our overly simplistic
> example this is not strictly necessary but in reality you might have pin
> conflicts between the different interfaces.
Same register, or same field/bits in that register?
If it's the same field/bits, I would expect to see the following pin groups:
1) PINS[0..3], PINS[8..9]
2) PINS[4..7]
... since those are the things that are independently muxable.
Otherwise, I'd expect to see the following groups:
1) PINS[0..3]
2) PINS[4..7]
3) PINS[8..9]
> After the discussion we had so far I'm not so sure if extending the
> pinctrl system with this kind of features is a very good idea.
That makes things simple:-)
One thing I still don't understand; in a previous mail, you'd mentioned
3 DT properties for configuring the pinmux; one represented the pin
group, one represented the mux function that was selected for that pin
group, and there was a third ("config"?) property. I still don't
understand that third property. I only see pins/pingroups and mux
functions in the diagram I quoted above.
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-doc" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
