Hi,
On Thu, Jul 14, 2022 at 8:31 PM quic_zijuhu <quic_zijuhu@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>
> On 7/15/2022 5:24 AM, Luiz Augusto von Dentz wrote:
> > Hi Zijun,
> >
> > On Thu, Jul 14, 2022 at 12:14 AM Zijun Hu <quic_zijuhu@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> >>
> >> A cvsd sco setup failure issue is reported as shown by
> >> below btmon log, it firstly tries to set up cvsd esco with
> >> S3/S2/S1 configs sequentially, but these attempts are all
> >> failed with error code "Unspecified Error (0x1f)", then it
> >> tries to set up cvsd sco with D1 config, unfortunately, it
> >> still fails to set up sco with error code
> >> "Invalid HCI Command Parameters (0x12)", this error code
> >> terminates attempt with remaining D0 config and marks overall
> >> sco/esco setup failure.
> >>
> >> It is wrong D1/D0 @retrans_effort 0x01 within @esco_param_cvsd
> >> that causes D1 config failure with error code
> >> "Invalid HCI Command Parameters (0x12)", D1/D0 sco @retrans_effort
> >> must not be 0x01 based on spec, so fix this issue by changing D1/D0
> >> @retrans_effort from 0x01 to 0xff as present @sco_param_cvsd.
> >
> > Please quote the spec regarding the invalid parameters:
> >
> BLUETOOTH CORE SPECIFICATION Version 5.3 | Vol 1, Part F
> page 375
>
> 2.18 INVALID HCI COMMAND PARAMETERS (0x12)
> The Invalid HCI Command Parameters error code indicates that at least one of
> the HCI command parameters is invalid.
> This shall be used when:
> • the parameter total length is invalid.
> • a command parameter is an invalid type.
> • a connection identifier does not match the corresponding event.
> • a parameter is odd when it is required to be even.
> • a parameter is outside of the specified range.
> • two or more parameter values have inconsistent values.
> Note: An invalid type can be, for example, when a SCO Connection_Handle is
> used where an ACL Connection_Handle is required.
>
> > BLUETOOTH CORE SPECIFICATION Version 5.3 | Vol 4, Part E
> > page 1891
> >
> > 0x01 At least one retransmission, optimize for power consumption (eSCO con-
> > nection required).
> >
> >> < HCI Command: Setup Synchrono.. (0x01|0x0028) plen 17 #3405 [hci0]
> >> Handle: 3
> >> Transmit bandwidth: 8000
> >> Receive bandwidth: 8000
> >> Max latency: 10
> >> Setting: 0x0060
> >> Input Coding: Linear
> >> Input Data Format: 2's complement
> >> Input Sample Size: 16-bit
> >> # of bits padding at MSB: 0
> >> Air Coding Format: CVSD
> >> Retransmission effort: Optimize for power consumption (0x01)
> >> Packet type: 0x0380
> >> 3-EV3 may not be used
> >> 2-EV5 may not be used
> >> 3-EV5 may not be used
> >>> HCI Event: Command Status (0x0f) plen 4 #3406 [hci0]
> >> Setup Synchronous Connection (0x01|0x0028) ncmd 1
> >> Status: Success (0x00)
> >>> HCI Event: Synchronous Connect Comp.. (0x2c) plen 17 #3408 [hci0]
> >> Status: Unspecified Error (0x1f)
> >> Handle: 4
> >> Address: 14:3F:A6:47:56:15 (OUI 14-3F-A6)
> >> Link type: eSCO (0x02)
> >> Transmission interval: 0x00
> >> Retransmission window: 0x00
> >> RX packet length: 0
> >> TX packet length: 0
> >> Air mode: CVSD (0x02)
> >> < HCI Command: Setup Synchrono.. (0x01|0x0028) plen 17 #3409 [hci0]
> >> Handle: 3
> >> Transmit bandwidth: 8000
> >> Receive bandwidth: 8000
> >> Max latency: 7
> >> Setting: 0x0060
> >> Input Coding: Linear
> >> Input Data Format: 2's complement
> >> Input Sample Size: 16-bit
> >> # of bits padding at MSB: 0
> >> Air Coding Format: CVSD
> >> Retransmission effort: Optimize for power consumption (0x01)
> >> Packet type: 0x0380
> >> 3-EV3 may not be used
> >> 2-EV5 may not be used
> >> 3-EV5 may not be used
> >>> HCI Event: Command Status (0x0f) plen 4 #3410 [hci0]
> >> Setup Synchronous Connection (0x01|0x0028) ncmd 1
> >> Status: Success (0x00)
> >>> HCI Event: Synchronous Connect Comp.. (0x2c) plen 17 #3416 [hci0]
> >> Status: Unspecified Error (0x1f)
> >> Handle: 4
> >> Address: 14:3F:A6:47:56:15 (OUI 14-3F-A6)
> >> Link type: eSCO (0x02)
> >> Transmission interval: 0x00
> >> Retransmission window: 0x00
> >> RX packet length: 0
> >> TX packet length: 0
> >> Air mode: CVSD (0x02)
> >> < HCI Command: Setup Synchrono.. (0x01|0x0028) plen 17 #3417 [hci0]
> >> Handle: 3
> >> Transmit bandwidth: 8000
> >> Receive bandwidth: 8000
> >> Max latency: 7
> >> Setting: 0x0060
> >> Input Coding: Linear
> >> Input Data Format: 2's complement
> >> Input Sample Size: 16-bit
> >> # of bits padding at MSB: 0
> >> Air Coding Format: CVSD
> >> Retransmission effort: Optimize for power consumption (0x01)
> >> Packet type: 0x03c8
> >> EV3 may be used
> >> 2-EV3 may not be used
> >> 3-EV3 may not be used
> >> 2-EV5 may not be used
> >> 3-EV5 may not be used
> >>> HCI Event: Command Status (0x0f) plen 4 #3419 [hci0]
> >> Setup Synchronous Connection (0x01|0x0028) ncmd 1
> >> Status: Success (0x00)
> >>> HCI Event: Synchronous Connect Comp.. (0x2c) plen 17 #3426 [hci0]
> >> Status: Unspecified Error (0x1f)
> >> Handle: 4
> >> Address: 14:3F:A6:47:56:15 (OUI 14-3F-A6)
> >> Link type: eSCO (0x02)
> >> Transmission interval: 0x00
> >> Retransmission window: 0x00
> >> RX packet length: 0
> >> TX packet length: 0
> >> Air mode: CVSD (0x02)
> >> < HCI Command: Setup Synchrono.. (0x01|0x0028) plen 17 #3427 [hci0]
> >> Handle: 3
> >> Transmit bandwidth: 8000
> >> Receive bandwidth: 8000
> >> Max latency: 65535
> >> Setting: 0x0060
> >> Input Coding: Linear
> >> Input Data Format: 2's complement
> >> Input Sample Size: 16-bit
> >> # of bits padding at MSB: 0
> >> Air Coding Format: CVSD
> >> Retransmission effort: Optimize for power consumption (0x01)
> >> Packet type: 0x03c4
> >> HV3 may be used
> >> 2-EV3 may not be used
> >> 3-EV3 may not be used
> >> 2-EV5 may not be used
> >> 3-EV5 may not be used
> >>> HCI Event: Command Status (0x0f) plen 4 #3428 [hci0]
> >> Setup Synchronous Connection (0x01|0x0028) ncmd 1
> >> Status: Success (0x00)
> >>> HCI Event: Synchronous Connect Comp.. (0x2c) plen 17 #3429 [hci0]
> >> Status: Invalid HCI Command Parameters (0x12)
> >> Handle: 0
> >> Address: 14:3F:A6:47:56:15 (OUI 14-3F-A6)
> >> Link type: SCO (0x00)
> >> Transmission interval: 0x00
> >> Retransmission window: 0x00
> >> RX packet length: 0
> >> TX packet length: 0
> >> Air mode: u-law log (0x00)
> >
> > This really sounds like the controller fault, it seem to be picking up
> > SCO based on packet type alone instead of checking if retransmission
> > is suggesting to use eSCO instead, otherwise there is no use to define
> > D1/D0 for both eSCO and SCO since the controller will always pick SCO
> > instead.
> >
> i don't agree with you about above opinion:
> S3/S2/S1 here is for eSCO but D1/D0 is for SCO, it should try to set up
> SCO after all eSCO setup failures based HFP_v1.8 spec, so it is reasonable to
> return "Invalid HCI Command Parameters" for SCO setup with retransmission parameter
> 0x01 since SCO doesn't need retransmission.
>
> the spec doesn't say it is available for D1/D0 on eSCO.
>
> Hands-Free Profile V1.8 | page 133
>
> 5.7.1.1 Selection of Synchronous Transport
> To select the type of synchronous transport (eSCO or SCO) to use, devices shall adhere to the following
> logic:
> • If eSCO is supported by the responder, the synchronous connection shall first be attempted on an
> eSCO logical transport. See section 5.7.1.2
> • If eSCO is unavailable for use (e.g., not supported by the Responder or link establishment fails),
> and SCO is not currently forbidden because a BR/EDR secure connection is being used, the
> Initiator shall open a SCO logical connection. See section 5.7.1.3.
>
> Hands-Free Profile V1.8 | page 115
> 5.7.1.3 Negotiation of SCO Configuration Parameters
> Requirements related to the use of SCO links, under the conditions when the use of a SCO logical
> transport is permitted, are covered by the parameter sets D0-D1.
>
> Hands-Free Profile V1.8 | page 24
> shows a summary of the mapping of codec requirements on link features for this profile.
> Feature Support in HF Support in AG
> 1. D0 – CVSD on SCO link (HV1) M M
> 2. D1 – CVSD on SCO link (HV3) M M
> 3. S1 – CVSD eSCO link (EV3) M M
> 4. S2 – CVSD on EDR eSCO link (2-EV3) M M
> 5. S3 – CVSD on EDR eSCO link (2-EV3) M M
If D0-D1 are SCO only, then yes but then they should not even be part
of the eSCO table, still I don't think the controller should be
looking just to packet type or these types are not supported in eSCO?
> >> Signed-off-by: Zijun Hu <quic_zijuhu@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> >> Tested-by: Zijun Hu <quic_zijuhu@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> >> ---
> >> net/bluetooth/hci_conn.c | 4 ++--
> >> 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)
> >>
> >> diff --git a/net/bluetooth/hci_conn.c b/net/bluetooth/hci_conn.c
> >> index 7829433d54c1..2627d5ac15d6 100644
> >> --- a/net/bluetooth/hci_conn.c
> >> +++ b/net/bluetooth/hci_conn.c
> >> @@ -45,8 +45,8 @@ static const struct sco_param esco_param_cvsd[] = {
> >> { EDR_ESCO_MASK & ~ESCO_2EV3, 0x000a, 0x01 }, /* S3 */
> >> { EDR_ESCO_MASK & ~ESCO_2EV3, 0x0007, 0x01 }, /* S2 */
> >> { EDR_ESCO_MASK | ESCO_EV3, 0x0007, 0x01 }, /* S1 */
> >> - { EDR_ESCO_MASK | ESCO_HV3, 0xffff, 0x01 }, /* D1 */
> >> - { EDR_ESCO_MASK | ESCO_HV1, 0xffff, 0x01 }, /* D0 */
> >> + { EDR_ESCO_MASK | ESCO_HV3, 0xffff, 0xff }, /* D1 */
> >> + { EDR_ESCO_MASK | ESCO_HV1, 0xffff, 0xff }, /* D0 */
> >> };
> >
> > This doesn't seem right, you are changing the parameters for eSCO
> > table not SCO, which further reinforce this is probably the controller
> > not really doing its job and checking if retransmission is actually
> > meant for eSCO rather than SCO.
> >
> here it is D1/D0 SCO setup after S3/S2/S1 eSCO attempts failure as above my comments.
Well then all we need to do is to remove the last 2 lines since they
are already handled by the table below.
> >> static const struct sco_param sco_param_cvsd[] = {
> >> --
> >> The Qualcomm Innovation Center, Inc. is a member of the Code Aurora Forum, a Linux Foundation Collaborative Project
> >>
> >
> >
>
--
Luiz Augusto von Dentz
