Hi Chris, On Tue, Mar 1, 2022 at 1:26 AM Chris Clayton <chris2553@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Hi Luiz, > > I guess you are hoping for PEBKAC :-) > > On 28/02/2022 21:20, Luiz Augusto von Dentz wrote: > > Hi Chris, > > > > On Mon, Feb 28, 2022 at 1:02 PM Chris Clayton <chris2553@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > >> > >> Hi Luiz, > >> > >> On 28/02/2022 19:34, Luiz Augusto von Dentz wrote: > >>> Hi Chris, > >>> > >>> On Sat, Feb 26, 2022 at 12:04 AM Chris Clayton <chris2553@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > >>>> > >>>> Hi, > >>>> > >>>> On 24/02/2022 15:16, Luiz Augusto von Dentz wrote: > >>>>>> I'll try another bisection today, but limit its range to changes made in the net/bluetooth directory. > >>>> > >>>> That bisection has proved very difficult because the bluetooth "service" in kernels at some steps of the bisection were > >>>> completely borked to the extent that blueman's device-manager application wouldn't start and emitted the messages: > >>>> > >>>> blueman-manager 12.00.37 ERROR Manager:137 on_dbus_name_appeared: Default adapter not found, trying first available. > >>>> blueman-manager 12.00.37 ERROR Manager:141 on_dbus_name_appeared: No adapter(s) found, exiting > >>>> > >>>> Obviously, I don't know whether the problem I am trying to pinpoint is hiding behind this more fundamental problem with > >>>> the bluetooth "service", so being unable to say whether that kernel was good or bad, I had to skip. There seems to be a > >>>> batch of commits that mean that, whilst the kernel builds okay, hunting down a bluetooth-related problem is not > >>>> possible. Eventually and I cursed and gave up. Whatever was causing this breakage has obviously been fixed. > >>>> > >>>>> Please record the HCI with btmon, it must be producing something since > >>>>> it records even the mgmt commands. > >>>>> > >>>> > >>>> Refreshed by a good night's sleep, I started another bisection (between 5.16 and 5.17-rc1) yesterday morning but this > >>>> time did not limit it to net/bluetooth. That was going okay until I ran into what I assume is the same batch of borked > >>>> kernels. I've been more persistent this time but have just had a run of 16 steps in which the bluetooth support in the > >>>> kernel is broken so badly that testing bluetooth is not possible. I will push on today, but I've suspended that activity > >>>> to get the hci trace that Luiz has asked for. > >>>> > >>>> Using information from the bisect, I built a kernel that had tested as bad (but not borked). The commit is > >>>> f2b551fad8d8f2ac5e1f810ad595298381e0b0c5. As I've mentioned before, the problem with devices not connecting is > >>>> intermittent - for a given kernel, sometimes a connection works and other times it doesn't. On the first boot of this > >>>> kernel, my bluetooth devices could connect, Attached are 4 files related to this - the output from btmon, and the > >>>> related portions of daemon.log, kern.log and sys.log from /var/log/. Each of the these files is suffixed with ".good". > >>>> > >>>> I then powered down the laptop and booted into the same kernel. This time the bluetooth devices could not connect. Four > >>>> more files are attached for this boot and are suffixed with ".bad". I said in an earlier email that when connection > >>>> fails, there is no output from btmon, so that log is empty. That's still the case, but I guess that fact itself is a > >>>> clue to what the problem might be. What I can add, however, is that if, in that same bad kernel, I unload and then > >>>> reload the btusb module, connections start to work. Maybe that too is a clue. The same unload/load process revives > >>>> bluetooth on a kernel built after a pull of Linus' latest and greatest this morning. > >>>> > >>>> Since I now have a workround, I'm going stop the current bisection that I was doing. I've done another couple of steps > >>>> this morning and both produced kernels on which I could not test bluetooth and had to tell git bisect to skip. If > >>>> however, I can provide any other diagnostics, please let me know. > >>>> > >>>> Chris > >>> > >>> Can you try with the following patch: > >>> > >>> https://patchwork.kernel.org/project/bluetooth/patch/20220228173918.524733-1-brian.gix@xxxxxxxxx/ > >>> > >>> > >> Sorry, that patch has made no difference. After the first boot my headphones connected okay, but after a power-down and > >> reboot they would not connect without an unload and reload of the btusb module. > > > > Can you tell us exactly what steps you are using? Are you applying on > > top of what, rc6? > > > > Until I got your patch yesterday, I was using a clone of > git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git which I update frequently and have been doing so for as > long as I can remember. Just in case there was a hidden flaw in that tree, I took a new clone yesterday, (so yes, the > patch was tested on top of rc6) copied over the .config file and applied the patch. Then I built and installed the > kernel, updated grub, powered off the laptop and booted into the new kernel. Once the laptop had booted and logged in to > my LXQt desktop, I powered on my headphones and a connection was establisehed almost straight away. I powered the > headphones off and the disconnection worked fine. > > Knowing that the problem crops up intermittently, I then rebooted the laptop. When the boot was complete, I then powered > on my bluetooth headphones an waited for them to connect to the laptop. After about 20 seconds, a connection had not > been established. I powered off the headphones, used modprobe to unload and then reload the btusb module. When I powered > on the headphones, a connectiin was established within 2 or 3 seconds. > > I've booted this laptop countless times over the last few days. Doing the bisect, I didn't mark a commit as good until I > had done five boots and been able to connect my headphones on each boot. What I can say from that work is that two > consecutive boots into a working kernel are very rare. I can't remeber an occasion when it took more than two boots to > establish that a kernel was bad. Do commands such as bluetoothctl power on or scan on works? Try running bluetoothd -dn from a shell (disable bluetooth.service), also are there any settings changed in main.conf? -- Luiz Augusto von Dentz
