On Wed, Aug 13, 2014 at 10:16 PM, Len Ovens <len@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
the trace shows MIDI messages. there are no 10 or 14 bit MIDI messages. only "controllers" with 14 bit state. 14 bit state is sent as two messages (when necessary). the tracer shows each individual message.
Is it just me? Has anyone else looked at pitch bend events on the Ardour MIDI Tracer? Quick test:
================================================
- edit->Preferences->Control surfaces.
- select both enabled and feedback for generic MIDI.
- double click on it and select bcf2000 with mackie protocol
- open an external midi monitor (using qmidiroute here) and connect it to
Ardours MIDI control out.
- also open Ardours MIDI tracer window and connect it to the same output.
(Now qmidiroute will be in decimal and MIDI Tracer is hex..)
- use the mouse to move the gain up and down on channel one with an audio track.
=================================================
I am seeing numbers that make sense on qmidiroute -8013 to 8177, but midi Tracer only shows two hex digits ever, shouldn't there be four (maybe three to handle 10bits)? It looks like I am seeing only the LSB (I am not sure about this as the lowest nyble should be 0). My about box says 3.5.308 so maybe this has been fixed since then. 3.5.380 seems to be were things are at now. I have looked through the change logs here: https://ardour.org/whatsnew.html for 3.5.380, (this doesn't seem to be included in the source package for 3.5.380) and https://ardour.org/news/3.5.older.html which is included with the source package. And I don't see any mention of a fix.
BTW, I am having lots of fun with my "MIDI" controler project. Built around a $3 USB computer keyboard from dollar store. I use two columns for each strip for 10 strips. Strip one for example is 1->z and 2->x. 1 is channel select (does nothing right now), 2 is record, q&w are pan control, a&z are the fader, s is solo and x is mute. up and down changes banks
Ah, banks. I have bank at 5 and am using 8 channels to test. It starts on channel 1 to 5, bank right does 6 to 8 (good so far), then another bank right does channel 8. I don't know if this is right or wrong, but my expectation is that once my controller has even one strip outside the range of channels that I would no longer be able to bank right. I would also expect the GUI to make sure all the channels my controler can control to be visible. My thought is that in the same way a selected track gets a red border (in the mixer) perhaps a green border around the group of tracks in the current bank. The BCF2000, for example, does not give much indication visually of where the banks are at. Mine of course gives none, but I could make a GUI across the bottom of the screen the controler sits in front of that does that... it just seems redundant when the mixer is already on the screen just above. I do realize that the controler code at least for the MCP stuff is not complete and will get done when it gets done. What I have already is a wonderful step up.
The transport is on the numeric pad.
All of this could easily change as I add some encoders for pan/faders
the trace shows MIDI messages. there are no 10 or 14 bit MIDI messages. only "controllers" with 14 bit state. 14 bit state is sent as two messages (when necessary). the tracer shows each individual message.
_______________________________________________ Linux-audio-user mailing list Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
