>>> Can anyone explain is there any benefits of using WinASIO (with JACK)? > >> So you can use windows music programs under wine with low latency and >> midi control. To add to this, WineASIO allows you to run windows binaries that support ASIO. WineASIO essentially just hands off the buffers to jack ~ where as FSThost or FST allow you to instead host/wrap a single VST (instrument or effect) to use with jack. WineASIO uses alsa-midi as well, not jack-midi. (so you likely have to pick the midi port in the app with alsa-midi vs. connecting the ports in your graph with jack-midi). > But with much MIDI jitter between WineASIO and Linux. Tested a long time > ago with Reaper. Serious usage was impossible. Ralf, you are quite incorrect on this point. I don't know when you did these tests, but i know several people whom run Reaper just fine (and have been, for quite some time ~ ie: for years). While i don't personally use Reaper, i have tested it (recently) quite a bit. ~ assuming you have a decent setup (both in s/w and h/w + wine-rt patch and reaper setup correctly), Reaper runs just fine, including using lots of VSTi/VSTs in your tracks, recording audio tracks, multiple midi tracks, etc... ie: no xruns / very usable. I've had some pretty heavy tracks going, with some of the heavier VSTi's running, (including Kontakt 5, Massive, Ivory, etc) no problem, whatsoever. (although, Kontakt does require L_Pa-Wine to run properly, normal wine / wine-rt doesn't cut it for Kontakt). I'd also like to point out, that i have been using wineASIO in several of my 'Rigs'/RackmountPCs, spanning 5yrs... If 'serious usage' was impossible with WineASIO - i would not be able to use it, in my setups at all. (which is obviously not the case). imho, It sounds like you must have had some poor configuration on your end, if you were not able to successfully use WineASIO + midi without issue. cheers Jordan _______________________________________________ Linux-audio-user mailing list Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
