Paul Davis wrote:
On Wed, Jan 26, 2011 at 11:51 AM, James Morris<jwm.art.net@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
[...]
Why is OSC support not more widespread?
because there are almost no standards for OSC. this is not a protocol
like MIDI that defines semantics. there is no standard way, for
example, to tell an "OSC supporting app" to "start playing". an OSC
sender has to know a lot about the OSC receiver. this severely limits
OSC's usefulness (but does not make it zero by any means).
I wonder if it could make sense/be interesting for this community to
put forward some effort in this direction. That is, discussing and then
trying to agree on a standard (broad meaning intended) for
audio/music-aware applications, hardware etc. that use OSC... could be
'LADOSC' :)
I'm no OSC expert myself, and am grateful to the James for opening the
discussion which has already given me various interesting pointers and
insights.
I've always been looking at OSC as better alternative to MIDI, but
(partly due to usual laziness of course) have also looked at the
familiarity and 'cosiness' of the good ol' MIDI standard.
A first step might be to try 'porting' all standard MIDI stuff to some
agreed OSC scheme, exploiting the latter's functionality. For e.g. one
apparently trivial, but IMHO iportant aspect, is the fact that precision
isn't limited to 127 like in MIDI.
Another aspect is: apart from real-time use, how is osc 'recored'? Would
a simple timestamped list of OSC messages do? What about time
resolution? Is this (persistence) aspect relevant? Does it make sense to
think of OSC-files similar a la MIDIfiles?
Just some thoughts/ideas
Lorenzo.
For instance, could/should there be an OSC tab in QjackCTL?
could there be? if someone added OSC port support to JACK (which is
relatively easy to do), sure.
Should we not be able to create tracks in
muse/qtractor/seq24/rosegarden that output to OSC to provide all the
advantages OSC gives over MIDI?
ardour4 will support this. for whatever that's worth.
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list
Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list
Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
