Le 16/10/2024 à 09:23, Fons Adriaensen a écrit :
Hello all,
The purpose of this post is to gather some opinions on the
use of 'tape distortion' plugins.
The way an analog magnetic tape recorder distorts the signal
is quite complicated. The non-linear response is mainly due
to the hysteresis of the magnetisation process, and how this
interacts with the HF bias added to the recorded signal.
Simplifying things a bit, as the tape moves past the recording
head and away from it, it goes through several cycles of an
hysteresis loop with decreasing amplitude, and it finally
converges to some value more or less proportional to the signal.
The bias signal itself does not remain on the tape, or at most
at a very low level.
The same process but with just a very high level HF bias is
used to erase the tape.
Simulating this accurately is quite complicated, and very CPU
intensive. The sample rate must be at least twice the bias
frequency (around 100 kHz for 'pro' equipment) and for each
sample you need to evaluate the hysteresis loop up to a hundred
times (depending on tape speed) to simulate the convergence.
Over the past few months I've written the code to do this,
with the aim to present a useful 'tape emulation' plugin
at the next LAC. It uses a somewhat simplified form of the
Preisach algorithm for the hysteresis.
<http://kokkinizita.linuxaudio.org/linuxaudio/downloads/preisach-model.pdf>
But the first results are somewhat sobering.
Have a look at
<http://kokkinizita.linuxaudio.org/linuxaudio/downloads/tapesaturation.png>
This shows the tranfer function (recorded magnetic signal as
a function of the input) for three values of the HF bias.
The blue line is what you get without bias. It result in a
very smooth saturation for high level signals, but a low
amplitude signal will be severly distorted due to the flat
region around zero.
As bias level is increased, this effect is reduced and the
low level gain increases up to some maximum. This is shown
by the orange curve.
The recommended way to set the correct bias level is to
further increase it until the small signal gain is reduced
by a few dB (typically 1 or 2 dB, depending on tape type).
This is shown by the green curve.
The central part of this is very linear (less than 1% THD).
But now the smooth saturation is almost transformed into
hard clipping. The sharp bend in the curve occurs when the
signal amplitude is higher than the bias amplitude.
The only effect that remains in a complete simulation is
the result of the EQ applied to the signal to be recorded.
Higher frequencies have a 'self erasure' effect (which is
nicely reproduced by the simulation) and so need to be
amplified. The net result is that they will saturate at
a lower input level.
How much EQ is required depends mainly on tape speed, higher
speeds need less. At the most popular 'pro' speed (381 mm/s)
this would be something around 10 dB at 10 kHz. At the higher
(762 mm/s) speed typically used for 'master tapes' it's just
a few dB.
So what does effectively remain of the 'smooth saturation
and compression' that is claimed to give tape recording its
magical 'warm' character ? Is it just a myth ?
I also simulated the green curve directly without going
through the complicated full simulation, and honestly,
to me that sounds just the same. And unless you really
use very high levels (much more than would actually be
used) the net effect is marginal. Maybe the hard clipping
can be useful when applied to individual tracks (e.g.
drums or bass), but then there are much simpler ways
to do this than 'tape emulation'.
Comments invited !!
Although the focus here is on signal reproduction, for truly realistic
tape simulation
maybe later wow-and-flutter and dropouts could be simulated.
It always seemed, at least with cassette, that even a brand new
mid-to-high-end machine
with a fresh tape has these problems, according to our measuring
instruments.
If these might be considered inherent defects of tape systems, then why not
even go a bit further and add other real-world defects which occur
later on.
One setting picks the tape drive: From cheap cassette deck to pro
reel-to-reel.
Another setting picks the type of 'defect': From cheap DC capstan motors to
felt idler clutch pads whose fibers magically compress over time in
such a way
as to cause 'micro-dragging' which increases the flutter - or even
squealing noises,
to cheap miniature pinch rollers, or pinch rollers that have become
warped or dirty.
Another setting picks the tape, but also simulates how many times it's
been played:
From pristine unopened box to 'your older brother's Van Halen/Led
Zeppelin car mix tape'.
Cheers.
Tim.
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list -- linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to linux-audio-user-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
