Not long ago I watched "Pianomania", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piano mania , tuning the grand piano by this documentation has less to do with A = foobar Hz. More important seems to be the consistency of the grand piano's mechanic and tuning within whatever is the chamber pitch. Apart from this, a friend of mine, Achim Jaroschek, a much praised German Jazz pianist and drummer, a while back owned 2 Bechstein and one Baldwin grand piano. All grand pianos were tune relatively good to his taste, but we were unable to do a good home recording, due to the missing microphones for this task. What ever the chamber pitch might be, more important is the consistency of the tuning, not necessarily regarding the pitch, but regarding the emotions of the piano player, regarding the consistency of the grand pianos behaviour and apart from this, as soon as you want to record the piano, much more important is the available gear. I really doubt that the tuning of the chamber pitch by itself does much affect the result of a performance. Indeed, decades ago, when I used the Roland MT-32, not with it's factory sounds, but with self edited sounds, that should emulate analog synth, I several times tuned it a little bit below 440Hz, because this added more warmth, while all the other analog and digital synth wer tuned to 440 Hz. However, when ever I tested pitches <> 440 Hz nobody ever listening to the recordings, including myself, felt better at any pitch higher or lower lower 440 Hz. A tuning that differs to 440 Hz could be important for live performance of classic orchestras for several reasons, but is most likely is irrelevant when making music with electronically instruments. Apart from this the tuning usually is higher than 440 Hz, due to loudness/transparency/brilliant, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concert_p itch#Pitch_inflation . In rock music guitarist's, I'm one myself, sometimes tend to either tune in relation to 440 Hz all strings a half tone lower, I don't, or as several people from my generation (generation x, aka grunch) and I do sometimes, drop the low E string to D, IOW just one string a whole step lower, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drop_D_tuning ;, however, A still remains at 440 Hz. Regards, Ralf _______________________________________________ Linux-audio-user mailing list Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
