On Thu, 21 Sep 2017 16:25:39 +0800 "XaviLi" <ljy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > We raised a topic about PPR (Per Page Recycler) and thank to Jan Kiszka > for advises. We are here to break up patch codes and explain the code > in detail. There are too many things to explain in one topic. We would > like to do it part by part. Content of original mails and patches can > be found below in the end. If you want these patches to be reviewed, you really need to submit a proper patch series. Please look at Documentation/process/submitting-patches.rst for all the details. You will also want to make the code compliant with the kernel's coding style. I have not reviewed this code (nor am I really the person to do a proper review), but this jumped at me: > while(mark->desc != 0) > { > barrier(); > } Busy waits in the memory-management code are going to raise a lot of eyebrows, and you really need to document what you think that barrier() call is doing. I suspect it's not giving you the protection you think it is. jon