Re: First v3 RFC is published - RFC 8651 on Dynamic Link Exchange Protocol (DLEP) Control-Plane-Based Pause Extension

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 

On 07.10.2019 22:00, Heather Flanagan wrote:

Wow, everyone. We did it!

Thank you all for years and years of effort in getting us to this point.
RFC 8651 is now the first RFC to be published in the v3 format.

As those of you on the xml2rfc list know, there are still heated
discussions underway about some aspects of the XML vocabulary. Getting
the -bis documents out to capture the reality of the v3 format is
critically important. That is in the top 3 priorities for me as I wrap
up my time as RSE (the other two are operational transition items and
the RFC Model process discussion).

I particularly want to thank the RPC staff. They have worked incredibly
hard to fill the roles of expert copyeditors, quality assurance
engineers, and key stakeholders throughout the seven years (and
counting) of the RFC format project. This is an amazing team. Thank you.

Heather Flanagan, RSE
...


So, as far as I can tell, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8651.xml> -
which is supposed to be the canonical format - does not conform to the
V3 grammar (neither the one from RFC 7991, nor what's in the unpublished
RFC 7991bis):


C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:93:96: error: attribute "bare" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "empty", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:93:96: error: attribute "indent" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:95:150: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:95:250: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:96:104: error: attribute "bare" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "empty", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:96:104: error: attribute "indent" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:98:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:98:256: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:103:150: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:103:287: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:106:150: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:106:266: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:107:104: error: attribute "bare" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "empty", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:107:104: error: attribute "indent" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:109:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:109:270: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:110:112: error: attribute "bare" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "empty", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:110:112: error: attribute "indent" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:112:174: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:112:306: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:117:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:117:248: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:120:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:120:252: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:125:150: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:125:272: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:128:150: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:128:264: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:129:104: error: attribute "bare" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "empty", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:129:104: error: attribute "indent" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:131:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:131:278: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:134:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:134:270: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:137:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:137:302: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:142:150: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:142:246: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:143:104: error: attribute "bare" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "empty", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:143:104: error: attribute "indent" not allowed here; expected attribute "anchor", "pn", "spacing", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:145:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:145:278: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:148:162: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:148:282: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:153:155: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:153:258: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:156:155: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:156:263: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "pageno", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:166:144: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:179:88: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:182:139: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:184:139: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:187:163: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:188:124: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:200:134: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:201:138: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:209:90: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:209:176: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:221:134: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:224:152: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:288:96: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:347:196: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "format", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:347:196: error: attribute "section" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "format", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:347:196: error: attribute "derivedLink" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:431:92: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:468:113: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:507:96: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:534:102: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:563:134: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:565:134: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:575:114: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:581:139: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:593:88: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:607:127: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:608:120: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:633:127: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:634:120: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:667:118: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:668:110: error: attribute "sectionFormat" not allowed here; expected attribute "derivedContent", "pageno", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:711:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:711:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:726:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:726:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:741:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:741:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:770:197: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:770:197: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:794:199: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "target", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:794:199: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:815:151: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:815:151: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:825:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:825:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:848:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:848:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:877:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:877:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:903:128: error: attribute "quoteTitle" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:903:128: error: attribute "derivedAnchor" not allowed here; expected attribute "quote-title", "xml:base" or "xml:lang"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:937:70: error: element "author" not allowed here; expected the element end-tag or element "artset", "artwork", "aside", "blockquote", "dl", "figure", "iref", "ol", "section", "sourcecode", "t", "table", "texttable" or "ul"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:951:72: error: element "author" not allowed here; expected the element end-tag or element "artset", "artwork", "aside", "blockquote", "dl", "figure", "iref", "ol", "section", "sourcecode", "t", "table", "texttable" or "ul"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:965:82: error: element "author" not allowed here; expected the element end-tag or element "artset", "artwork", "aside", "blockquote", "dl", "figure", "iref", "ol", "section", "sourcecode", "t", "table", "texttable" or "ul"
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:106:266: error: IDREF "name-extension-data-items" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:120:252: error: IDREF "name-restart" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:153:258: error: IDREF "name-acknowledgments" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:103:287: error: IDREF "name-extension-usage-and-identif" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:109:270: error: IDREF "name-queue-parameters" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:131:278: error: IDREF "name-extension-type-value" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:145:162: error: IDREF "section-6.1" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:148:162: error: IDREF "section-6.2" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:134:270: error: IDREF "name-data-item-values" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:128:264: error: IDREF "name-iana-considerations" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:125:272: error: IDREF "name-security-considerations" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:137:302: error: IDREF "name-queue-parameter-sub-data-ite" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:106:150: error: IDREF "section-3" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:103:150: error: IDREF "section-2" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:95:150: error: IDREF "section-1" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:142:150: error: IDREF "section-6" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:128:150: error: IDREF "section-5" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:125:150: error: IDREF "section-4" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:148:282: error: IDREF "name-informative-references" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:156:155: error: IDREF "section-appendix.b" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:153:155: error: IDREF "section-appendix.a" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:117:248: error: IDREF "name-pause" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:120:162: error: IDREF "section-3.3" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:131:162: error: IDREF "section-5.1" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:134:162: error: IDREF "section-5.2" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:137:162: error: IDREF "section-5.3" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:95:250: error: IDREF "name-introduction" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:112:174: error: IDREF "section-3.1.1" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:156:263: error: IDREF "name-authors-addresses" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:112:306: error: IDREF "name-queue-parameter-sub-data-it" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:142:246: error: IDREF "name-references" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:145:278: error: IDREF "name-normative-references" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:98:162: error: IDREF "section-1.1" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:98:256: error: IDREF "name-key-words" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:109:162: error: IDREF "section-3.1" without matching ID
C:\projects\xml2rfc\rfc8651.xml:117:162: error: IDREF "section-3.2" without matching ID


Best regards, Julian
[Index of Archives]     [IETF Annoucements]     [IETF]     [IP Storage]     [Yosemite News]     [Linux SCTP]     [Linux Newbies]     [Mhonarc]     [Fedora Users]

  Powered by Linux