On Tue, Dec 04, 2018 at 04:42:57PM +0000, Alexey Melnikov wrote: > On 04/12/2018 15:24, IESG Secretary wrote: > >The Last Call on draft-faltstrom-unicode11-05 has been cancelled, and > >the document's state has been changed back to "AD Evaluation." > > > >For more information about IESG states for Internet-Drafts, please see > ><https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/help/state/draft-iesg/> > > Based on private feedback received during the first day of IETF LC I decided > to cancel IETF LC. Two main points of this feedback: > > 1) Document status might be wrong, because it is updating Proposed > Standards, while itself being Informational. I mean, that's the sort of nit that LC can raise as needing to be fixed, but not the sort of nit that should cause LC to fail or be cancelled. > 2) Suggestion to ask Internationalization Directorate (to be formed shortly) > to review this document before proceeding further. In particular there were > concerns that interactions with other drafts to be reviewed by the > Directorate might require changes to this document. > > Hopefully Internationalization's Directorate review can be done before the > end of the year, so that I can restart IETF LC. Usually there is no ordering requirement between IETF LC and directorate review (the directorates being informal advisors to the IESG). However, if I18N directorate does not exist yet, and that could mean that IETF LC could complete long before the directorate review, then I think it's quite fair to hold up the IETF LC until the directorate is up and running. Nico --
