--On Tuesday, January 24, 2017 11:40 -0500 John R Levine
<johnl@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>> Have you read the spec, or are you just responding to my notes
>> and/or Patrik's?
>
> I reread the spec, which was a good idea. It says the domain
> names can contain U-labels and NR-LDH ASCII labels, which
> seems correct. That forbids both A-labels and dodgy stuff
> that looks like A-labels but isn't.
Thanks. That is consistent with my impression. My concern is
that the language and terminology won't make it clear about what
is being specified unless someone is _really_ familiar with IDNA
and the "EAI" specs. It meshes with Patrik's concern that the
wording of the spec won't be clear to someone who is not _very_
good with English.
My impression is that there is little problem with the intended
underlying spec, but the document text needs some tuning.
john