>Dave Crocker wrote: > >>Yes, but how does (or should) your comment affect the draft charter text? S Moonesamy wrote: > > I'll quote from > http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/ietf-announce/current/msg13031.html > > "Existing deployment of DMARC has demonstrated utility at internet > scale" I would propose to adjust this statement to better match reality. > "Existing deployment of DMARC has demonstrated moderate success > for some providers and some parts of the internet, and at the > same time interferes fatally with mailing list usage of > DMARC-affected EMail user accounts and mail forwarding. > > But the by far most serious problem is that processing of EMail > according to DMARC by a telecommunicatios service provider > is a real and serious criminal offense in countries with strong > protections of fundamental human rights, such as many member > countries of the European Union, and this precludes that > DMARC could ever scale to the entire internet. -Martin