On Fri, Apr 18, 2014 at 7:47 AM, <ned+ietf@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Allow me to rephrase: "We think getting our commerical mail through is worthThe message was pretty clearly, "We think DMARC is valuable enough to us
that we plan to deploy it even though it has the unfortunate side effect
of causing problems for mailing lists."
sacrificing all sorts of personal mail functionality users depend on. And we
don't care who it hurts, including some shops as large or larger than we are."
I'm not so sure delivery is the primary goal. Rather, "We're tired of the fact that we are unable to control who generates mail that appear to come from our domain(s), and it's hurting us" is how that should at least start. A tarnished domain name has repercussions beyond just delivery of email.
-MSK