On Sun, Mar 03, 2013 at 03:55:39PM +0000, Eggert, Lars wrote: > only if the Y directorate reviews all IDs going through the IESG. Which in itself is a scaling issue. It may work for some topics, but things will fall through the cracks for various reasons. > > IMO congestion control is important and fundamental enough that the IESG itself needs to have the knowledge. YEs, I'm biased. Searching for "Congestion Control Expert" on google shows no real matches at all before this discussion thread. I could find "Unicorn expert" though. I wonder if those would make a good TSV AD. Would you mind to describe how to evaluate someone to meet the bar to be CCE in your opinion ? I ask because starting to populate this new term into googles cache doesn't mean its clear whether the community would even have a common idea of what it would mean. Independent of whether the community thinks its a good bar for TSV-AD in the first place.