Le 2012-11-27 à 13:00, Barry Leiba a écrit :
So here's my question:
Does the community want us to push back on those situations? Does the
community believe that the real IETF work is done on the mailing
lists, and not in the face-to-face meetings, to the extent that the
community would want the IESG to refuse to publish documents whose
process went as I've described above, on the basis that IETF process
was not properly followed?
no. Our work is done both on mailing lists and f2f meetings. As co-chair of a few wg, we have been doing great progress during f2f meeting with high-bandwidth interactions.
so document shepherd and AD should exercise judgement on how to see the community consensus/participation.
Marc.
I realize that this question is going to elicit some vehemence.
Please be brief and polite, as you respond. :-)
Barry, Applications AD