--On Wednesday, August 03, 2011 16:49 -0400 Jorge Contreras <cntreras@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > John, > > I'll jump in to save Marshall the trouble. I was asked by the > IESG to put together a straw man first draft in collaboration > with Scott Bradner. From what I see, many IDs are developed by > a couple of authors before submitting to the larger IETF. is > that unusual? Clearly the intention is to have full community > engagement, but 1200 people can't write a first draft (or at > least not very well...) Jorge, We are supposed to have some very specific rules about design teams, especially ones that are commissioned by WG Chairs or equivalent to prepare drafts. Given "asked by the IESG to put together...", your effort qualifies as such a design team. Under those rules the relevant parts of the community are supposed to be informed of the effort. When, for example, Russ initiated the work that led to RFC 5680, there was such an announcement. Finding out by accident doesn't constitute "informed". Unless the IESG has decided recently to exempt itself from that rule, your effort is not off to a good start. regards, john _______________________________________________ Ietf mailing list Ietf@xxxxxxxx https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf