Paul Hoffman wrote:
On 1/31/11 12:23 AM, Lars Eggert wrote:
On 2011-1-30, at 17:12, Paul Hoffman wrote:
The above emphatic statements means that IANA can reject a request
for an IETF-approved protocol that needs two ports without recourse.
I don't follow. Assignments through IETF-stream documents do not go
through expert review.
Then this should be made *much* clearer in the document.
I believe this was clarified in -10.
In fact, the document says:
A key element of the procedural streamlining specified in this
document is to establish identical assignment procedures for all IETF
transport protocols.
I assumed that "all" meant "all", not "all except those through
IETF-stream documents"; others might have read it the same way I did.
Further, the wording throughout the template description in 8.1 makes
it sound like that the restrictions in this document apply to
everything that needs a template, which clearly includes IETF-stream
documents.
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf