Dear Sir, Like other members of the multilinguistic working list to which I belong, since 2002 I received a copy of the mails exchanged between JFC Morfin and your organization, on IDNs then langtags. And we have often discussed them. I do not thus ignore big matter of this subject As JFC Morfin got everything we wanted except again: (1) that the WG-IDNABIS quickly demonstrates the merits of IDNA or finds a better solution. (2) that the RFC 4646 is respected by the IESG what also calls for the RFC 4646bis underway. I proposed to replace him as an IETF watcher, given the importance of his current work. In two months, I sent a half-dozen of messages and received courteous answers. Of course I expected a possible ostracism. I was prepared to respond with kind understanding. This was the case with Brian Carpenter. He accused me of being JFC Morfin in an humorous but a way a little hurtful. We exchanged and he had the courtesy to apologize willingly and and to inform the IESG about it. I would have done the same with Randy Preshun if contacted me, even impolitely, even after having ignored my question about a significant breakthrough for us he implied, even after that he probably pushed a "trap" by misrepresenting our position and that of ISO. Instead, he dashes into a guerilla of racist censorship against me: it is because of the MLTF ideas that he accuses me of not being me. 2008/3/20, Randy Presuhn <randy_presuhn@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>: > Hi - > > There have been expressions of support, and no objections on this list, > to the proposed metric (and one off-list objection by JFC Morfin) for > identifying possible sock-puppets of those whose posting privileges > have been revoked pursuant to RFC 3683. So, we're using it. > > We engaged the procedure with three independent working group participants. > All three identified the same email address, which was also identified by the > responsible area director and both co-chairs. Consequently, future postings > from lbleriot@xxxxxxxxx will not be delivered, since we believe this address > is a sock-puppet for JFC Morfin. > > Randy > ltru co-chair You will understand that I have reached an age where I am not impressed anymore and that I have time for a good cause: -- or Randy Preshun apologizes and it stays there. -- or he has suspended my rights without warning and is preparing for a PR action against me without any reason. He does it with the support of our two direct commercial competitors in his WG. Under these conditions you will understand that I am not to be giving anything that enables them to validate a practice of arbitrary exclusion of the IETF. Today I, whom tomorrow? -- LB _______________________________________________ IETF mailing list IETF@xxxxxxxx https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf