Thanks to IAB for the review. Inline: > The IAB does not oppose a scoped experiment. Great! > However, As the IAB reviews BOFs and WG charters (see RFC 2850 section > 2.1) as part of its architectural oversight function, we believe that > the IAB should also review SG charters. Of course. I think this has been the assumption, but it does deserve to be clarified in the document. Authors, take notice... > We also recommend that the evaluation criteria for success are made > clear before the start of the experiment. Ok. I assume you mean evaluation criteria for the success of the experiment, not the success of an SG? Jari _______________________________________________ Ietf@xxxxxxxx https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf