>>>>> "Joel" == Joel M Halpern <joel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:
Joel> After re-read Brian's draft, RFC 3683, RFC 3934, and the
Joel> relevant portions of RFC2418 I support the IESG/ADs ability
Joel> to make longer than 30-day suspensions and to engage in
Joel> alternate methods of mailing list control, as described in
Joel> 2418. I agree that the IESG having only the option of 1
Joel> year suspension, as required by RFC 3683, is unduly
Joel> restrictive, does not help us, and should be rescinded. If
Joel> 3683 were rescinded without explicitly restoring the ability
Joel> to make longer suspensions, then we would have to explain
Joel> what other courses of action we did intend to have
Joel> available. Hypothetically, there might be some better
Joel> alternative, so I am not coupling my response to the two
Joel> questions.
To clarify, I have not issued the last call yet, I was just forwarding David's discuss comment to the appropriate list and letting people know how I plan to proceed.
There's no need to re-respond to the LC when it does come out though.
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf