Sam Hartman wrote:
"JFC" == JFC (Jefsey) Morfin <jefsey@xxxxxxxxxx> writes:
JFC> On 09:53 03/10/2005, Brian E Carpenter said:
>> JFC (Jefsey) Morfin wrote:
>>> http://www.neustar.com/pressroom/files/announcements/ns_pr_09282005.pdf
>>> Comments welcome. Is it to be understood as an alt-root? or is
>>> it a legitimate hower single operator?
>> Neither. .gprs appears to be a private pseudo-TLD inside a
>> walled garden for GPRS operators. It doesn't have anything to
>> do with the Internet's namespace. .3gppnetwork.org appears to
>> be a perfectly normal Internet 2LD.
JFC> Dear Brian, I have difficulty in understanding this. You talk
JFC> of "Internet's name space". I feel difficult to reconcile
JFC> this with an NGN approach. Also with the Internet as the
JFC> network of the networks of different technologies? IMHO there
You know, I have to agree with Jefsey here, at least up to this point.
I was not able to understand the rest of the message. But his point
is valid: walled gardens will leak.
What may leak are attempts to resolve .gprs names in the Internet,
which will generate bogus queries to a root server. I don't think
this is a good thing, obviously. But it isn't catastrophic.
Brian
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf