>>>>> "Keith" == Keith Moore <moore@xxxxxxxxxx> writes:
Keith> You seem to think that the IETF isn't accountable because
Keith> they make decisions that you don't like. I assure you from
Keith> having been there that there is significant pushback
Keith> against IESG people who do things that WG participants
Keith> don't like. Appeals are painful enough for everyone on
Keith> IESG that even the implied threat of appeal is a powerful
Keith> incentive to craft a compromise.
I'd like to second this. There are several accountability mechanisms.
ADs get significant pressure when they make a decision that people
don't like from the people effected, from the working group chairs,
from the rest of the IESG and in some cases from the IAB.
I also believe the nomcom process does provide accountability. I
think that the nomcom interview process was more comprehensive than
any job interview process I've gone through.
I suspect the nomcom does get a lot of feedback about sitting IESG/IAB
members and it seems likely that on average they seriously consider
this feedback.
--Sam
_______________________________________________
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf