Hi Peter,
On 3/10/25 04:46, Peter van Dijk wrote:
If a positive DSYNC answer results,
This appears to be legit English, but it is phrased uncommonly, causing
spurious reboots in human readers :-)
I'm not sure what causes the mental reboot :) Do you have a suggestion for improvement?
Perhaps "If the result is a positive DSYNC answer," or closer to your
version "If this results in a positive DSYNC answer,".
Done!
(And perhaps, 4.3 step 1 should be doing more than
flipping the QR bit - it should also remove the report-channel option. This
seems obvious so I wonder if we need to be explicit here.)
NEW
1. Acknowledge receipt by sending a NOTIFY response as described in
[RFC1996] Section 4.7 (identical to NOTIFY query, but with QR bit
set and any EDNS0 Report-Channel options removed) [...]
Most EDNS options do not want to be mirrored in responses. I think -less-
explicit language is better here. Perhaps just remove the entire bit in
()
Done!
Changes are here: https://github.com/peterthomassen/draft-ietf-dnsop-generalized-notify/commit/ffe8308c648ec5ed75d5efed09de1beb9ecd2d64
Cheers,
Peter + co-authors
--
last-call mailing list -- last-call@xxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe send an email to last-call-leave@xxxxxxxx
