A comment made to microphone in OPSAWG is that the most expensive energy component of routing is probably the RF and optical segment, and if you have any kind of redundancy in routing, you cannot turn these off. I cant say if this is true or not, I don't know the core ASIC cost to perform switching. So I take this on trust. The general tone to the comments was "can we stick to the tractable part of the problem and not wade into things which are political" (my words) -Not that you are, just to round out what I think I heard in the room. Basically, this conversation is in OPSAWG: https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/114/materials/agenda-114-opsawg-01 cheers -G On Fri, Aug 5, 2022 at 9:12 AM Hesham ElBakoury <helbakoury@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > There has been some discussions in IETF 114 about how to reduce the > network energy consumption and carbon footprint. Most of the > energy-aware routing and traffic engineering publications that I have > seen rely on powering down network elements such as interfaces, line > cards and routers to save power. The problems with this approach are: 1) > to power up these elements when they are needed may take long time which > may cause undesirable service disruption, and 2) network operators may > not trust routing and traffic engineering software to power down and up > these elements without operator intervention. > > To address these problems we may do one of the following: > > 1- Do not power down any network element, and try some other way to > reduce energy such as adjusting the cooling level based on network load. > > 2- Do not power down any network element, but put the element in low > power idle state to consume least amount of power while it is not used > to forward traffic. In this state it is quicker to bring the element > into fully operational state. This solution may require hardware support. > > 3- Use traffic analysis and modeling techniques perhaps with AI/ML > algorithms to predict which elements to power down/up and when, in such > a way to avoid service disruption. > > 4- Use renewable energy, store it in the router and return back to the > energy source the energy that is not used so that someone else can use it. > > 5- If you have other approaches, please let us know. > > In all these approaches we need to instrument the network to monitor its > traffic loading and energy consumption. > > Comments ? > > Hesham >
