Harald, > Harald Tveit Alvestrand > But there's absolutely no doubt in my mind that the WG made a > decision, and that the chairs were procedurally correct in > recording that decision as the outcome of the meeting. There many people, including some that actually _wrote_ the procedures, that disagree with you. As of myself, I am not completely happy with the way Tony has worded his appeal (although I do agree with it), which is why I will file one on different grounds as soon as this one as been ruled. Since it appears that there is a waiting list to file an appeal on this matter, I am sure that we will be entertained for the next two or three years to come. Michel.