On 10/26/2015 05:14 AM, Niels de Vos wrote: > On Wed, Oct 21, 2015 at 05:22:49AM -0400, Nagaprasad Sathyanarayana wrote: >> I came across the following BZs which are still open in mainline. But >> they are fixed and made available in a upstream release. Planning to >> close them this week, unless there are any objections. > > We have a policy to close bugs when their patches land in a released > version. The bugs against mainline will get closed when a release is > made that contains those fixes. For many of the current mainline bugs, > this would be the case when glusterfs-3.8 is released. Some of those bugs are pretty old. We haven't been good about closing them when a 3.X.0 release has occurred. I sent email to the lists about closing some of the older ones with a note to reopen them if they're still valid. The bugs with RFE in the subject, or RFE or FutureFeature as a keyword need to be left open after a 3.X.0 release if appropriate. I'm going to take a stab at guessing — based on the date the bug was filed — at changing the version of the non-RFE bugs filed against mainline. > > What is the concern of having bugs against the mainline version open > until a release contains that particular fix? There are many bugs that > also get backports to stable versions (3.7, 3.6 and 3.5). Those bugs get > closed with each minor releases for that stable version. > > Of course we can change our policy to close mainline bugs earlier. But, > we need to be consistent in setting the rules for that, and document > them well. There is an ongoing task about automatically changing the > status of bugs when patches get posted/merged and releases made. Closing > mainline bugs should be part of that process. > > When do you suggest that a bug against mainline should be closed, when > one of the stable releases containst the fix, or when all of them do? > What version with fix should we point the users at when we closed a > mainline bug? > > Our shiny docs (or my bookmarks?) are broken again... > http://gluster.readthedocs.org/en/latest/Developer-guide/Bug%20report%20Life%20Cycle/ > http://gluster.readthedocs.org/en/latest/Developer-guide/Bug%20Triage/ > > This is the old contents: > http://www.gluster.org/community/documentation/index.php/Bug_report_life_cycle > http://www.gluster.org/community/documentation/index.php/Bug_triage > > I was about to suggest to send a pull request so that we can discuss > your proposal during the weekly Bug Triage meeting on Tuesdays. > Unfortunately I don't know where the latest documents moved to, so > please send your changes by email. > > Could you explain what Bugzilla query you used to find these bugs? We > have some keywords (like "Tracking") that should be handled with care, > and probably should not get closed even when patches were merged in > mainline and stable releases. > > Thanks, > Niels > > >> >> 1211836,1212398,1211132,1215486,1213542,1212385,1210687,1209818,1210690,1215187,1215161,1214574,1218120,1217788,1216067,1213773,1210684,1209104,1217937,1200262,1204651,1211913,1211594,1163561,1176062, >> 1219784,1176837,1208131,1200704,1220329,1221095,1172430,1219732,1219738,1213295,1212253,1211808,1207615,1216931,1224290,1217701,1223213,1223889,1223385,1221104,1221696,1219442,1224596,1165041,1225491, >> 1221938,1226367,1215002,1222379,1221889,1220332,1223338,1224600,1222126,1212413,1211123,1225793,1226551,1218055,1220713,1223772,1222013,1227646,1228635,1227884,1224016,1223432,1227904,1228952,1228613, >> 1209461,1226507,1225572,1227449,1220670,1225564,1225424,1200267,1229825,1230121,1228696,1228680,1229609,1229134,1231425,1229172,1232729,1208482,1169317,1180545,1231197,1188242,1229658,1232686,1234842, >> 1235216,1235359,1235195,1235007,1232238,1233617,1235542,1233162,1233258,1193388,1238072,1236270,1237381,1238508,1230007,1210689,1240254,1240564,1241153,1193636,1132465,1226717,1242609,1238747,1242875, >> 1226279,1240210,1232678,1242254,1232391,1242570,1235231,1240654,1240284,1215117,1240184,1228520,1244165,1243187,1243774,1209430,1196027,1232572,1202244,1229297,1246052,1246082,1238135,1245547,1234819, >> 1224611,1221914,1207134,1245981,1246432,1178619,1243890,1240598,1240949,1247930,1247108,1245544,1238936,1232420,1245142,1226223,1250441,1229860,1245276,1246275,1250582,1249499,1231437,1241274,1212437, >> 1245558,1250855,1226829,1230015,1251042,1209329,1235582,1251449,1248415,1245895,1221490,1250797,1240991,1243391,1240218,1207829,1236009,1244613,1255599,1213349,1232378,1225465,1254127,1250170,1240244, >> 1245045,1254863,1242819,1242421,1256580,1251824,1252808,1251454,1258334,1205596,1242742,1205037,1212823,1209735,1210712,1229948,1232001,1234474,1242030,1241133,1241480,1242041,1252410,1232430,1231876, >> 1218573,1240952,1233544,1244109,1239269,1218164,1218060,1211640,1204641,1230090,1225571,1231205,1232666,1234882,1235292,1234694,1233411,1231789,1240229,1239044,1247529,1207735,1251346,1200254,1200265, >> 1251857,1241895,1233246,1238054,1233624,1221131,1213752,1218854,1231738,1231257,1236561,1228415,1202758,1238188,1229139,1225328,1254167,1252825,1253309,1255310,1248298,1248521,1199985,1219637,1200082, >> 1210344,1260730,1231268,1218287,1216898,1217786,1205540,1214048,1213125,1240621,1214219,1213063,1215571,1240970,1236212,1245935,1254451,1248306,1238593,1218717,1250828,1215896,1235269,1211562,1206546, >> 1215660,1222840,1216960,1205624,1241054,1211570,1228112,1227803,1251121,1214222,1219032,1252121,1215122,1211264,1205545,1221270,1236128,1226881,1240577,1225330,1207029,1226005,1226307,1243753 >> >> Regards >> Naga >> _______________________________________________ >> Gluster-devel mailing list >> Gluster-devel@xxxxxxxxxxx >> http://www.gluster.org/mailman/listinfo/gluster-devel > _______________________________________________ > Gluster-devel mailing list > Gluster-devel@xxxxxxxxxxx > http://www.gluster.org/mailman/listinfo/gluster-devel > -- Kaleb _______________________________________________ Gluster-devel mailing list Gluster-devel@xxxxxxxxxxx http://www.gluster.org/mailman/listinfo/gluster-devel
