Re: [Gluster-users] Trying to use gluster using Virtual IP.

Sergio Traldi <sergio.traldi@xxxxxxxxxx> · Mon, 12 Jan 2015 15:06:54 +0100



    Hi David,

    thaks for the answer, but if I use the IP and one controller fall
    down (i.e. controller1) I can see from the client when I make a ll
    command of gluster volume just the files present in brick2
    "exported" by controller2.

    
    The iscsi can be access from multiple host, but we can not write
    from 2 hosts (controller1 and controller2) in the same LUN at the
    same time (filesystem is not cluster like OCFS or GPFS) but if
    controller1 is powered off, the controller2 can write to brick1
    attached via iscsi so the client when I do a ll command on the
    gluster volume display the entire volume made of brick1 and brick2.

    We would like to use VIP to not reconfigure the volume if one
    controller fall down.

    
    I try to do an example.

    We have controller1 192.168.1.10 and controller2 192.168.1.11.

    If I create the volume like this:

    gluster volume create volume1 transport tcp
    192.168.1.10:/data/brick1/sda 192.168.1.11:/data/brick2/sdb

    
    If controller1 fall down in all the client we see just the data
    store in /data/brick2/sdb and if I want to the the files in brick1 I
    have to reconfigure like: (using IP fo controller2 for the 2 bricks)

    gluster volume create volume1 transport tcp
    192.168.1.11:/data/brick1/sda 192.168.1.11:/data/brick2/sd

    
    If we succeed to our configuration we could have this:

    We have controller1 192.168.1.10 with VIP 10.0.1.10 and controller2
    192.168.1.11 with VIP 10.0.1.11.

    
    We can create the volume like this:

    gluster volume create volume1 transport tcp
    10.0.1.10:/data/brick1/sda 10.0.1.11:/data/brick2/sdb

    
    If controller1 fall down the keepalived chage the 10.0.1.10 into
    192.168.1.11 and the /data/brick1/sda starts to be manage from
    controller2 and the client see the entire volume and all files in
    brick1 and brick2 without any reconfiguration.

    
    I hope I have clarified what we would like to do.

    Chees

    Sergio

    
    On 01/12/2015 02:14 PM, David Gibbons
      wrote:

    
      I use VIPs and keepalived on my production
        configuration as well. You don't want to peer probe with the
        VIP. You want to peer probe with the actual IP. The VIP is
        merely a forwarding-facing mechanism for clients to connect to,
        and that's why it fails between your gluster peers. The peers
        themselves already know how to handle failover in a more
        graceful way than a VIP :).
        
          
          Remove the peers then re-probe with the actual IP instead
            of the VIP. The VIP is just for clients. 
          

          Cheers,
          Dave
        
      
        On Mon, Jan 12, 2015 at 7:57 AM, Sergio
          Traldi <sergio.traldi@xxxxxxxxxx>
          wrote:

          Hi,

            We have a SAN with 14 TB of disks space and we have 2
            controllers attached to this SAN.

            
            We want to use this storage using gluster.

            
            Our goal is to use this storage in high availability, i.e.
            we want to keep using all the storage even if there are some
            problems with one of the controllers.

            
            Our idea is the following:

            - Create 2 LUN

            - Attach via iscsi the 2 LUN to each Controller Hosts.

            - Create a brick on each controller node (brick1 for
            Controller1 and brick2 for Controller2)

            - Make the login so each controller are able to mount disk1
            to brick1 and disk2 to brick2.

            - Install keepalived (a routing software where its main goal
            is to provide simple and robust facilities for loadbalancing
            and high-availability to Linux).

            - Create 2 VIP (Virtual IP) one for controller 1 and the
            other for controller 2. So the situation would be:

              o Controller1 with his IP (IP1) would have also a VIP
            (VIP1) with 2 iscsi disks mounted but just one in R/W mode
            used (brick1).

              o Controller2 with his IP (IP2)and a VIP (VIP2) with 2
            iscsi disksmounted but just one in R/W mode used (brick2).

            
            - The glusterfs volume would be mounted on the client in
            fail-over, i.e. in the fstab there would be something like:

            
            VIP1:/volume /var/lib/nova/instances glusterfs
            defaults,log-le

            vel=ERROR,_netdev,backup-volfile-servers=VIP2 0 0

            
            - Keepalived would be configured to change VIP1 to IP2 if
            controller1 e.g. has to be shutdown. The same for VIP2.

            This VIP change should hopefully not impact the operations
            on the client

            
            We are trying this setting but when we try to create a
            volume:

            gluster volume create testvolume transport tcp
            VIP1:/data/brick1/sda VIP2:/data/brick2/sdb

            
            we obtain this error:

            volume create: testvolume : failed: Host VIP2 is not in
            'Peer in Cluster' state

            
            But if we try :

            [controller1]# gluster peer status

            Number of Peers: 1

            
            Hostname: VIP2

            Uuid: 6692a700-4c41-4e8d-8810-48f9d1ee9315

            State: Accepted peer request (Connected)

            
            [controller2]# gluster peer status

            Number of Peers: 1

            
            Hostname: IP1

            Uuid: 074e9eea-6bf5-4ac8-8ac9-d1159bb4d452

            State: Accepted peer request (Disconnected)

            
            If we try to:

            [controller2]# gluster peer probe VIP1

            
            we obtain this error:

            peer probe: failed: Probe returned with unknown errno 107

            
            Any idea how I can not create a volume with two virtual IP?

            
            Thinking it could be a DNS problem I try also to put in
            /etc/hosts this lines:

            VIP1 controller1.mydomain controller1

            VIP2 controller2.mydomain controller2

            
            In each controller.

            
            In the log file of controller2 I just found:

            
            [2015-01-12 11:42:47.549545] E [glusterd-handshake.c:1644:__glusterd_mgmt_hndsk_version_cbk]
            0-management: failed to get the 'versions' from peer
            (IP1:24007)

            
            In the log file of cotnroller1 I just found:

            
            [2015-01-12 11:44:44.229600] E [glusterd-handshake.c:914:gd_validate_mgmt_hndsk_req]
            0-management: Rejecting management handshake request from
            unknown peer IP2:1018

            [2015-01-12 11:44:47.234863] E [glusterd-handshake.c:914:gd_validate_mgmt_hndsk_req]
            0-management: Rejecting management handshake request from
            unknown peer IP2:1017

            [2015-01-12 11:44:50.240324] E [glusterd-handshake.c:914:gd_validate_mgmt_hndsk_req]
            0-management: Rejecting management handshake request from
            unknown peer IP2:1001

            
            If I try a telnet:

            [controller2]# telnet VIP1 24007

            
            and

            [controller1]# telnet VIP2 24007

            
            they work fine.

            
            Any idea if it is possible create a volume using VIPs and
            not IPs?

            Cheers

            Sergio

            _______________________________________________

            Gluster-users mailing list

            Gluster-users@xxxxxxxxxxx

            http://www.gluster.org/mailman/listinfo/gluster-users

          
_______________________________________________
Gluster-devel mailing list
Gluster-devel@xxxxxxxxxxx
http://www.gluster.org/mailman/listinfo/gluster-devel