Jeff King <peff@xxxxxxxx> writes: > On Mon, Sep 07, 2015 at 02:51:42PM -0300, Renato Botelho wrote: > >> Default variables used to build are set using = on Makefile, (e.g. CC, >> INSTALL, CFLAGS, …). GNU make overwrite these values if it’s passed as >> an argument (make CC=clang) and it works as expected. >> >> Default method of passing arguments for make operations on FreeBSD >> ports tree is using environment variables instead of make arguments, >> then we have CC set on env before call gmake. Today these values are >> ignored by git Makefile, and we ended up patching Makefile replacing = >> by ?= on variable assignments [1]. > > Hmm. I can't really think of a downside to doing so, unless we expect > users to have things like CC set in the environment and _not_ want them > to bleed through to our build. I do think that is the reason behind the choice. I am not saying I necessarily personally agree with it, though. Common things like CC are not so problematic, but more problematic are various Git build customization in our Makefile that can be left behind from a previous build. It is easier for users to forget, as a "GIT_FOO=NoThanks; export GIT_FOO" that was run previously in the same shell does not leave trace once the shell exits, compared to other avenues of customization including config.mak and explicit command line settings given to the 'make' utility (i.e. can be seen in 'history' as a single entry, without having to trace the sequence of 'GIT_FOO=NoThanks', 'export GIT_FOO' and possible 'unset GIT_FOO' to find what was in effect when 'make' was run). So from that point of view, if you encourage users to be less explicit by keeping them in the environment, you are making it easier for the users to hurt themselves. In an environment to build with a "make world" style propagation of settings from top-level to down below, "environment bleeding" is a non-issue. It is merely a convention in that build environment how the settings are passed to submakes in a whole system and everybody in that environment understands the ramifications. I agree that your suggestion of using "gmake -e" may be a good workaround for handling cases like that. -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html