On Tue, 21 Nov 2006, Peter Baumann wrote: > > And I think handling this behaviour as a config option is the right thing, > because most of the time if someone imports a project into git he > will import the whole history, especially if he is using one of the > cvs/svn importers. A "halfway import" as seen in the kernel repo is a > special case and it is unlikely seen again. Actually, I see "halfway imports" all the time. I've found that some of the git things like "git grep" etc are _so_ convenient, that whenever I get a source tar-ball for _anything_, I tend to do zcat < xyz-123.tar.gz | tar xvf - cd xyz-123 git init-db git add git commit -m "Import xyz-123" the first thing I do. Even if I never end up changing anything in that archive, it's just that convenient (and fast - sure, doing the hashing and compression means that the "git add" might not be truly instantaneous, but it's definitely fast enough that for almost all projects, doing this is so cheap that you don't need to care). And _especially_ for things like this, being able to do "git log -p" to check the small trivial one-liners that I might do is nice (it happens - my pine4.64 import these days has three small commits to add buildnotes and handle UTF-8 input etc). And again, that's when you do _not_ want to see "--root". Because it's never what you actually care about. So I think imports are important. They may be throw-away trees like mine, but they're still useful. Linus - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html