On 10/15/06, Petr Baudis <pasky@xxxxxxx> wrote:
> I am still working with the developers of the cvs2svn import tool to > fix things so that Mozilla CVS can be correctly imported. There are > still outstanding bugs in cvs2svn preventing a correct import. MozCVS > can be imported, but the resulting repository is not entirely correct. > > Once they get the base cvs2svn fixed I'll port my patches to turn it > into cvs2git again. So what exactly is the cvs2git status now? AFAIU, there's a tool that parses the CVS repository and that is then "piped" to git-fastimport? git-fastimport is available somewhere (perhaps it would be interesting to publish it at repo.or.cz or something), is the current cvs2git version available as well?
cvs2git is a set of patches that get applied to cvs2svn. The patches modify cvs2svn to output things in a format that git-fastimport can consume. The problem is that there are issues with cvs2svn and how it converts CVS into change sets that are not getting fixed. These issues are annoying for SVN users but they are fatal for git. The exact problem is a bug in the way CVS symbol dependencies are dealt with in cvs2svn. The bug results in most branches and symbols being based off from 5-7 different change sets instead of a single change set. SVN then copies from the 5-7 change sets to build the branch base or symbol base. Copying from the 5-7 change sets is addressing the symptoms of the bug instead of fixing the underlying problem which is incorrect ordering of the base change sets. -- Jon Smirl jonsmirl@xxxxxxxxx - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html