Michael J Gruber-2 wrote: > > Tim Mazid venit, vidit, dixit 01.11.2009 10:31: >> >> Hi all, >> >> I've noticed that if I create a headless tag (one that doesn't have a >> branch, right?), when I click on that commit, it doesn't have precedes or >> follows information. Is this by design? Is there a work-around I can use >> without creating a branch there? > > Reposting (without even saying so) doesn't necessarily increase your > chance of getting responses. > I didn't repost. Or at the least, I didn't mean to repost. The mailing list kept complaining (spamming me) that my post was pending, and I eventually realised that was the old forum. I deleted it from there, and copy-pasted here. I didn't even realise it had posted here, and that when I deleted from the old forum, it didn't delete here. Michael J Gruber-2 wrote: > > Would would help: > > - saying you're talking about gitk/git view/whatever it is you're > "clicking" on > My apologies, yes, in gitk. Michael J Gruber-2 wrote: > > - providing a minimal example others can reproduce. That would be one > where a tag on a detached head (assuming that's what you mean) has no > precedes/follow but a tag "on a branch" does have that info > Example (unless specified, commands as entered into bash) mkdir temp cd temp git init gitk --all & git commit --allow-empty -m '1' git tag v1 git commit --allow-empty -m '1.1' git tag v1.1 git commit --allow-empty -m '1.2' git tag v1.2 (in gitk, press ctrl+f5; all follows and precedes info is there) git checkout v1.1 git commit --allow-empty -m '1.1.1' git tag v1.1.1 (in gitk, press f5; follows and precedes info missing for v1.1 and v1.1.1) (close gitk) gitk --all & (info still missing) git commit --allow-empty -m '1.1.2' git tag v1.1.2 (in gitk, press f5, info still missing) git checkout master git commit --allow-empty -m '1.3' git tag v1.3 (in gitk, press f5, info still missing) git commit --allow-empty -m '1.4' git tag v1.4 (in gitk, press f5, info still missing) git checkout -b temp v1.2 git commit --allow-empty -m '1.2.1' git tag v1.2.1 (in gitk, press f5, info still missing) git checkout master git branch -D temp git commit --allow-empty -m '1.5' git tag v1.5 (in gitk, press f5, info still missing) In the end, the only follows/precedes info is: v1: precedes v1.1 v1.1: follows v1, precedes v1.2 v1.2: follows v1.1 All the rest is missing. -- View this message in context: http://n2.nabble.com/Headless-tags-don-t-have-a-follows-or-precedes-tp3926483p3931674.html Sent from the git mailing list archive at Nabble.com. -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html