On 2009.04.06 01:35:24 +0300, Felipe Contreras wrote: > On Mon, Apr 6, 2009 at 12:58 AM, Markus Heidelberg > <markus.heidelberg@xxxxxx> wrote: > > Felipe Contreras, 05.04.2009: > >> For example 'git stage diff' is more natural (at least to me) than 'git diff > >> --cached', same goes for 'git stage rm foo.c' vs 'git rm --cached foo.c'. > > > > Not for me. If I want to GET a diff, I want to use a command "diff", so > > "git diff" is more obvious. > > The next step is to say WHAT exactly to diff. Therefor options to the > > "diff" command are more logically to me from a hierarchic POV. And here > > I don't think options like "--cached" or "sha1..sha2", despite having > > different style, make any difference. > > Well, it's a matter of preference, and you would not loose the option > to do it the way you like. But actually, "git diff --cached" is a > different action; you can't do "git diff --cached HEAD^.." for > example. Sure you can. It diffs the index against HEAD^ > Consider "git rm foo.c" vs "git rm --cached foo.c"... both commands > are removing a file, the only difference is that one is removing from > the staging area while the other is removing it from the working > directory. The working tree _and_ the index. To delete it only from the working tree you need "rm", not "git rm". > Now think about "git branch -d bar", following the "first I > specify the action, and then the object" thinking, would it make sense > to have "git rm --branch bar"? Probably not; if you want to do stuff > with branches, you use "git branch", similarly, if you want to do > stuff with the staging area, why not use "git stage"? If you're going that way, you'll also need "clone create", "working-tree grep", "repo/remote fetch/pull/push", etc. "git branch", "git tag", "git remote" and maybe "git status" are the "outsiders", in that the commands (in some forms) end up as "git <object> <action>" form. The rest is "git <action> <object>". So "git stage <action>" would extend the minority, and not lead to unification. Björn -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html