Seth Burgess <sjburges@xxxxxxxxx> writes: > Well, I strongly dislike having an eraser tool that > behaves differently based on a property of an image > you can't even see. It really stinks. > > What I'd prefer to see is a "replace color" paint tool > that can handle bgs or any other layer the way eraser > works now on a bg layer. > > Keeping the user experience the same between versions > is not a good thing when the user experience sucks. > > Seth I second this. We have too long stayed with this behaviour. I doubt that there a too many people using gimp for (and _only_ for) one layer images. If I once grokked the idea of layers, the current behaviour as it is strikes me as unintuitive even when working on single layer images. jtl